AES 2009 Audio Myths Workshop
Reply #150 – 2010-03-22 19:09:32
Last week I wrote:Am I the only person who has noticed that not one of the nay-sayers has presented a single audio example to prove their point? All they do is try to tear down all of the examples in my video, and call me wrong, but never once have they shown their own example and said what's right. Dwoz, please post some audio files showing that dither is audible on pop music recorded at sensible levels. Please post an example showing when jitter is audible. Please show us that phase shift can be heard. Please prove with an audio file that stacking is not a myth. And so forth. Now dwoz writes:I can construct a set of files that demonstrate a stacking effect that cannot be removed via an inverse function on the sum Coulda woulda shoulda. But never did. This is a big problem with you. It's called "All talk and no action." Look, whoever you are, I spent half a year preparing for that workshop. I created numerous graphs and drawings and audio examples to prove my points. Then I made a detailed video with all of those examples and highly detailed explanations. So far all I see from you is "You're wrong" with nothing to back it up. Again I ask , where are your examples proving that jitter, dither, usual amounts of phase shift, and stacking etc are an audible problem? Where is your hard proof that more than four parameters are needed to define fidelity? You've wasted hundreds of hundreds of posts around various forums trying to make your points, yet you have not once succeeded. Does that not tell you anything? --Ethan