Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: Hard to encode CD. Which one ? (Read 3267 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hard to encode CD. Which one ?

Hi from Italy and sorry for my bad english.

I need and "Hard to encode in MP3" whole CD for my mp3 tests and not only "saple clips" as Fatboy, Castanets or similar pieces.

Can You please tell me what CD (or CDs) is totally hard to encode for the kind of music it contains ?

Thanks


Daniele

Hard to encode CD. Which one ?

Reply #1 –
IIRC the harpsichord is a particularly difficult instrument to encode.  Perhaps you can find a CD featuring harpsichord compositions?

Hard to encode CD. Which one ?

Reply #2 –
Quote from: pecosbill76 on
Hi from Italy and sorry for my bad english.

I need and "Hard to encode in MP3" whole CD for my mp3 tests and not only "saple clips" as Fatboy, Castanets or similar pieces.

Can You please tell me what CD (or CDs) is totally hard to encode for the kind of music it contains ?

Thanks


Daniele



There is no a "famous hard to encode Cd" ?
I though there is, since there are a lot of "famous hard to encode pieces".

Sorry again for my english !

Hard to encode CD. Which one ?

Reply #3 –
The EBU SQAM disc is a test disc, created to include clean recordings of lots of instruments. It's not a normal music CD, but it does manage to contain a variety of hard to encode content. Lots of easy stuff to though.

http://sound.media.mit.edu/mpeg4/audio/sqam/

Apart from that, why not PM Guruboolez (a member here) to ask which solo harpsichord CD he would recommend for this purpose? You could look through the listening tests section to see what he has reported in the past.

Going back even further, the founder of this forum, Dibrom, worked hard to try to make mp3 encode his own choice of electronic music. He concluded that mp3 wasn't really up to the job, so some of his favourite albums might be good choices. You'll have to search back a long way in HA to find anything about this.

Myself, I don't know of any hard to encode discs - for example, I have the original CD with fatboy.wav on, and that's just the intro to one track on the CD - the rest of the track is easier to encode, as is the rest of the disc.

Lame really has become very good; a lot of the samples that used to trip it up are less of a problem now. Some of the weak points in lame are not a problem for FhG, so you cannot say that mp3 itself is at fault (other than sfb21, harpsichord(!) and may be temporal smearing, which all require high bitrates to solve/improve).

Your English is perfectly understandable.

Cheers,
David.