Skip to main content

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: Nero AAC Recommended Settings (Read 93521 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #50
I read/searched, but couldn't find an answer.  But was there ever a consensus on what to arguments to use with the command-line encoder for iPod compatibility AND to keep the file size low?

e.g.
-lc forces LC, but has a higher bitrate
leaving out -lc keeps the bitrate much lower, but may or may not be an LC AAC file

Strange enough, both files at Q0.5, but bitrates varying a lot.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #51
Just use -lc and tweak the -q setting until you get the kind of bitrate you like.

The bitrate only increases because the quality scale has a different base. The encoder doesn't suddenly get less efficient or anything.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #52
What is meant by iPod compatibility? Just to force LC profile I suppose? There are no compatibility issues are there?
Every night with my star friends / We eat caviar and drink champagne
Sniffing in the VIP area / We talk about Frank Sinatra
Do you know Frank Sinatra? / He's dead

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #53
The bitrate only increases because the quality scale has a different base.

I don't understand what that means exactly, but just to clarify, Q0.5 with and without -lc should sound the same, but the bitrates would just vary?

What is meant by iPod compatibility? Just to force LC profile I suppose? There are no compatibility issues are there?

Yup, I think iPods only do LC right now.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #54

The bitrate only increases because the quality scale has a different base.

I don't understand what that means exactly, but just to clarify, Q0.5 with and without -lc should sound the same, but the bitrates would just vary?


No. When you force -lc, the quality scale shifts, and Q0.5 doesn't have the same meaning as without -lc.

Basically, -q0.5 means "encode at some constant quality level". But when you force the encoder to LC mode, "-lc -q0.5" means "encode at some other constant quality level". The reasons for this are explained at length in other threads here.


As I stated already in my first answer, just lower the -q setting till you get the bitrates you want again.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #55
so what would the best setting for ~128kbps be?

I would assume 0.4, but foobar2000 has 0.41 = ~130kbps, so I'm a tad uncertain


Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #57
So just to clarify, using -q 0.5 without -lc will still be perfectly iPod compatible, because (at least right now) 0.5 is not using HE anyhow, correct?

And if I want to find the equivalent with -lc enabled, all I need to do is find a -q setting that gives the same bitrate on the same file, and it should be of identical quality to the -q 0.5 file without -lc? Nothing else will be going on there? Different lowpass for example?

I think this is a confusing design decision, while I understand the reasoning.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #58
I'm using this command line with EAC:

Code: [Select]
/c e:\nero_digital_audio\win32\neroaacenc.exe -q 0.5 -if %s -of %d && e:\nero_digital_audio\Neroaactag.exe %d -meta:artist="%a" -meta:album="%g" -meta:track="%n" -meta:title="%t" -meta:genre="%m" -meta:year="%y"


and it is producing m4a files that give the error:

Code: [Select]
Could not load info (Unsupported format or corrupted file (moov box not found)) from:
"E:\Documents and Settings\Benjamin Miller\My Documents\My Music\iTunes\glassjaw\Glassjaw  - Mu Empire.m4a"


when I attempt to add them to my foobar playlist. I have no idea what to do about this problem.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. I can provide the specs of my computer if needed.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #59
There is a link to this thread in the HA wiki. I am wondering if that link shouldn't point to the sticky instead of this thread. 

Also, all the wiki pages on AAC are all locked for editing. I'm a total noob to the wiki  but i thought the whole idea was that anyone could edit/contribute. What's the deal? 

Sorry if this isn't the place for this post, but I'm not sure where else to ask this question.

EDIT: Figured it out on my own (found the wiki forum) sorry for the post in the wrong place.

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #60
I'm using this command line with EAC:

Code: [Select]
/c e:\nero_digital_audio\win32\neroaacenc.exe -q 0.5 -if %s -of %d && e:\nero_digital_audio\Neroaactag.exe %d -meta:artist="%a" -meta:album="%g" -meta:track="%n" -meta:title="%t" -meta:genre="%m" -meta:year="%y"


and it is producing m4a files that give the error:

Code: [Select]
Could not load info (Unsupported format or corrupted file (moov box not found)) from:
"E:\Documents and Settings\Benjamin Miller\My Documents\My Music\iTunes\glassjaw\Glassjaw  - Mu Empire.m4a"


when I attempt to add them to my foobar playlist. I have no idea what to do about this problem.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. I can provide the specs of my computer if needed.


I know that this post is old, but I was having precisely the same problem when I encoded using the latest Nero AAC encoder, and I seem to have found what the problem was. I am using the command line from the sticky-thread about recommended Nero AAC settings, but I kept getting this "moov box not found" error over and over again. iTunes just refused to play it, and Quicktime said it was a format that it did not understand. The problem was that I had the "Add ID3 tag" option in EAC checked by accident, and unchecking it and redoing the rip/encode fixed the problem. I have searched for quite a while on HA and on Google, but nobody seemed to post a solution, so to anybody out there experiencing it, just something to try. 

Nero AAC Recommended Settings

Reply #61
Quote
Code: [Select]
Approx. average bitrate <-> Quality table

Bitrate          Quality
~15                 0.05    
~32                 0.15
~63                 0.25
~99                 0.35
~146                0.45
~197                0.55
~248                0.65
~299                0.75
~350                0.85
~401                0.95


For stereo, right? Multichannel would be higher?