Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Notice

If you are using a Hotmail or Outlook email address, please change it now, as Microsoft is rejecting all email from our service outright.
Topic: Best approach for same album names? (Read 931 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Best approach for same album names?

Hi I was thinking to add ' or ` to the end of the album name.. for those albums with the same name.. I wonder what do you guys do for situations like this? to prevent the songs from albums from merging.

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #1 –
That's exactly what the Album Artist tag is for :-)

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #2 –
it has the same album artist.. same contributed artist.. same year... everything is identical except for the number of songs and cover arts are different.
 

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #3 –
Call the edition with additional songs simply "Deluxe" or "Extended"

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #4 –
I too have 2 albums with only one song in.... is it a bad idea to name it " albumname` "? with a ` at the end of the album name will I run in to problem in future? because it doesn't seem appropriate to give it additional name like deluxe when it's not.. I could cause confusion next time when I google the album name and album name deluxe doesn't exist and started wondering why it's called deluxe or extended

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #5 –
In cases like this I usually add the record label/catalog number of the album to the title.

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #6 –
Quote from: suta on
it has the same album artist.. same contributed artist.. same year... everything is identical except for the number of songs and cover arts are different.

There must be something that differentiates the albums. Different release years, "deluxe" or "limited edition" branding, maybe it's a remaster.

I would add the relevant information after the albumtitle.

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #7 –
If it's really worth to keep both versions... maybe you could just choose one, and then pick missing tracks from another version and name it like "...My Album Name... (extra tracks from ...That Special Version...)"

If track listings are the same, I'd rather make a decision which variant I like more and keep only it. 
If both are lossless and I can't hear the difference, well, might just pick the smaller file size then.
some ANC'd headphones + AutoEq-based impulse + Meier Crossfeed (30%)

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #8 –
Quote from: suta on
Hi I was thinking to add ' or ` to the end of the album name
Same idea - I use a zero-width space. Album name looks identical, sorts separately.

I also use additional tags, since I prefer not having extra info added on to the album tag. I put that stuff in their own tags - %edition%, etc - and add some of them to playlist groupings.

Cheers

Re: Best approach for same album names?

Reply #9 –
I made my peace with this issue a long time ago. A simple:

Album Name
Album Name (Deluxe Version)

Don't forget to use the proper album cover for each version.
 
SimplePortal 1.0.0 RC1 © 2008-2021