Skip to main content

Topic: Need to transcoding AC3/MP3 to AAC (unfortunately...) (Read 2215 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
  • dragmore
  • [*]
Need to transcoding AC3/MP3 to AAC (unfortunately...)
hi. Im experimenting at work on a Harmonic Flexa RT transcoder where i need to transcode any audiosource to a specific AAC format.
My sources are typically AC3 @ 448, 384 kbps or Mpeg1-l2 at 256 or 384kbps.
The transcoder has the option of : LC-AAC, HE-AACv1, HE-AACv2 as output

Im trying to achieve as close to audio transparency as possible, and ive landed on 96kbps on HE-AACv1.. Is this a sane rationale?
In the situation i have both a 2channel AC3(448kbps) and a 2channel mp2 track (256kbps), which one would u use as source?

PS! Im fully aware that lossy to lossy will have impact on the quality, but in this context, passthrough aint an option..

/TE
  • Last Edit: 05 July, 2017, 04:48:37 AM by dragmore

  • Mark7
  • [*][*][*]
Re: Need to transcoding AC3/MP3 to AAC (unfortunately...)
Reply #1
He-aac is for very low bitrates, which will never be transparent. At 96kpbs lc-aac should be nearer to transparancy.

Any idea which aac encoder is used? This can make a huge difference.

Not sure about the ac3 vs mp2. They are both not very efficent.
I'd say listen very carefully (downmixed to stereo) and choose the better one.

  • saratoga
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
Re: Need to transcoding AC3/MP3 to AAC (unfortunately...)
Reply #2
In the situation i have both a 2channel AC3(448kbps) and a 2channel mp2 track (256kbps), which one would u use as source?

AC3 at such an extreme bit rate will be transparent.  You should use that.