Hydrogenaudio Forums

Hydrogenaudio Forum => General Audio => Topic started by: u2watcher on 2007-04-19 04:51:30

Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: u2watcher on 2007-04-19 04:51:30
Hi I just bought a Custom CD off Walmart Custom CDs site.  I thought well I can make a custom cd plus watch my money and hey im geting what I wanted.  The thing I am woundering is am I paying for mp3s? or Waves? When I get the CD it works in my everyday CD player and it sounds ok I think? what I mean about that is I feel like mabie i'm listening to mp3s.  Some songs sound different meaning worse then my mp3 copys like your think my old mp3s sound better.  I went on FAQ on site and it claims only as they will work on CD player.  What I am trying to figure out is are they giving me MP3s just burned on a cd?  The only reason is I thought I could make lossless audio of these when buying being they are lossless audio.  I thought this would sort of fit here in general audio since its a general audio type question.

Thanks
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: UED77 on 2007-04-19 05:18:50
Hi I just bought a Custom CD off Walmart Custom CDs site.  I thought well I can make a custom cd plus watch my money and hey im geting what I wanted.  The thing I am woundering is am I paying for mp3s? or Waves? When I get the CD it works in my everyday CD player and it sounds ok I think? what I mean about that is I feel like mabie i'm listening to mp3s.  Some songs sound different meaning worse then my mp3 copys like your think my old mp3s sound better.  I went on FAQ on site and it claims only as they will work on CD player.  What I am trying to figure out is are they giving me MP3s just burned on a cd?  The only reason is I thought I could make lossless audio of these when buying being they are lossless audio.  I thought this would sort of fit here in general audio since its a general audio type question.

Thanks


Though I am not familiar with their service, you can test the spectrum of the audio on the disc yourself and look for tell-tale lowpass.

Alternatively, there is a program called Tau Analyzer (http://www.true-audio.com/Tau_Analyzer_-_CD_Authenticity_Detector) by The True Audio project (makers of TTA, a lossless codec), that does just that: it tells you whether your CD was most likely made from lossless or lossy material.
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: RunawayTrane on 2007-04-19 05:21:31
Three songs for $4.62??? What a ripoff.
To coin a pharse from my man, Freddie Flintstone,
They must be out their rock-pickin minds!

Anyway, I checked the FAQ. They said nothig about quality.
I'm assuming there are selling MP3s though. That's what you
get when you download from them. 192K MP3's
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: u2watcher on 2007-04-19 05:50:18
here is  a pic of my scan what do you guys think? this is from the true real cd in my drive

(http://img178.imageshack.us/img178/1918/pagell1.th.jpg) (http://img178.imageshack.us/my.php?image=pagell1.jpg)

well I bought a custom cd they never said it was mp3s but I just wanted to see. I thought mabie i'd get lossless out of it since it made the play in everyday CD player claim

heres a update:
I just did my killers CD Sams Town and it comes up CDDA in status instead MPEG so yea I must admit I got screwed from Walmart.  That stuffs really misleading in FAQ about it being able to play in everyday CD player but really MP3s prob encoded into wave or whatever ripped with
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: Donunus on 2007-04-19 06:47:50
isn't what theyre doing illegal???
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: Spam Fodder on 2007-04-19 15:58:03
Hi I just bought a Custom CD off Walmart Custom CDs site.  I thought well I can make a custom cd plus watch my money and hey im geting what I wanted.  The thing I am woundering is am I paying for mp3s? or Waves? When I get the CD it works in my everyday CD player and it sounds ok I think? what I mean about that is I feel like mabie i'm listening to mp3s.  Some songs sound different meaning worse then my mp3 copys like your think my old mp3s sound better.  I went on FAQ on site and it claims only as they will work on CD player.  What I am trying to figure out is are they giving me MP3s just burned on a cd?  The only reason is I thought I could make lossless audio of these when buying being they are lossless audio.  I thought this would sort of fit here in general audio since its a general audio type question.
Thanks


did you see this link?  i'd say it apply (& let them know why):
<http://www.walmart.com/returns/returns_how.gsp>
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: mp3's suck on 2009-02-23 03:18:29
The Walmart CUSTOM CD's are not MP3 files.  They are uncompressed files just like you would receive on a store bought CD.  This is why they limit you to 80 minutes on a CD because that all a CD can hold at uncompressed file sizes.  I have ordered these and double checked them after receiving them.  They are a great way to get individual songs.

Unfortunately, I just received an email from Walmart announcing that they are discontinuing the program on March 2, 2009.
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: ameyer17 on 2009-02-23 03:54:40
Doesn't mean they aren't lossily compressed files that were decompressed to WAV.

Moderation: Removed useless quote of previous post.
Title: Walmart Custom CDs
Post by: shakey_snake on 2009-02-23 18:54:19
@ "mp3's suck"
All tracks on Red Book audio CDs are obviously stereo 16-bit 44.1KHz PCM.
You've added nothing to the conversation. Thanks for the needless bump.

This was a question of provenance.
SimplePortal 1.0.0 RC1 © 2008-2020