HydrogenAudio

Lossy Audio Compression => Other Lossy Codecs => Topic started by: kekchoos on 2024-01-20 19:17:19

Title: lossywav - is it worth a try?
Post by: kekchoos on 2024-01-20 19:17:19
I found out about the existence of this codec quite recently. It took me until today to get it working. A little background: I have a separate computer running Windows 7. I use it to work with my music collection and audio books. To convert music I try to use foobar2000. First I tried the latest version, which ended up with a lot of errors. So I switched to version 1.5.5. This version works fine. My settings are as follows:

Code: [Select]
/d /c C:\foobar2000\encoders\lossyWAV.exe - --quality 0 --silent --stdout|C:\foobar2000\encoders\wavpack.exe -q --blocksize=512 --merge-blocks -i - %d

Question: Are these the optimal ones? If not, for Red Book CD and 24/96, which ones would be "slightly better" than average?

Is there much difference between lossywav with these settings and qaac tvbr 127?
Title: Re: lossywav - is it worth a try?
Post by: Porcus on 2024-01-20 19:46:44
You already use WavPack, so why not instead WavPack hybrid with correction files - and a without them on the hard drive constrained computer?
Title: Re: lossywav - is it worth a try?
Post by: kekchoos on 2024-01-20 20:09:32
You already use WavPack, so why not instead WavPack hybrid with correction files - and a without them on the hard drive constrained computer?

I thought about it and even tried it. But I came across some threads on this forum where lossywav was very colorfully advertised, so I decided to give it a try.
Title: Re: lossywav - is it worth a try?
Post by: shadowking on 2024-01-21 02:01:45
Without correction data , Flac + lossywav @ 400k or more is more flexible.
With correction files wavpack is a good option. For hi-res audio lossywav hasn't been tested as much , So WV may be better.

lossywav vs aac quality, In general if going for much less than 400k , AAC may be better and easier option. From 400k , its expected to be on par and exceed aac. I don't think there are reports of lossywav 400 problems and maybe there are a few reports of aac problems @ 320