Hello,
running the 2 versions of R128GAIN
- R128GAIN v1.0.alpha5 and
- R128GAIN v1.0.alpha6-2
on the EBU R128 test vector
the results are not the same, alpha 6-2 is giving wrong results.
How is that possible?
Thanks
Jean
R128GAIN v1.0.alpha5
DlgItemUrl sucessfully loaded.
SoX sucessfully loaded.
FFmpeg sucessfully loaded.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\1
analyzing ...
[1/3] "1kHz Sine -20 LUFS-16bit.wav": -20.0 LUFS (-3.0 LU)
peak: -19.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[2/3] "1kHz Sine -26 LUFS-16bit.wav": -26.0 LUFS (3.0 LU)
peak: -25.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[3/3] "1kHz Sine -40 LUFS-16bit.wav": -40.0 LUFS (17.0 LU)
peak: -39.8 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[ALBUM]: -22.0 LUFS (-1.0 LU)
peak: -19.9 TPFS, range: 20.0 LU
done.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\2
analyzing ...
[1/9] "seq-3341-1-16bit.wav": -23.0 LUFS (-0.0 LU)
peak: -22.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[2/9] "seq-3341-2-16bit.wav": -33.0 LUFS (10.0 LU)
peak: -32.7 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[3/9] "seq-3341-2011-8_seq-3342-6-24bit-v02.wav": -23.0 LUFS (0.0 LU)
peak: -2.6 TPFS, range: 15.3 LU
[4/9] "seq-3341-3-16bit-v02.wav": -23.0 LUFS (0.0 LU)
peak: -23.0 TPFS, range: 13.0 LU
[5/9] "seq-3341-4-16bit-v02.wav": -23.0 LUFS (0.0 LU)
peak: -23.0 TPFS, range: 13.0 LU
[6/9] "seq-3341-5-16bit-v02.wav": -23.0 LUFS (-0.0 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 6.0 LU
[7/9] "seq-3341-6-5channels-16bit.wav": -23.0 LUFS (0.0 LU)
peak: -24.0 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[8/9] "seq-3341-6-6channels-WAVEEX-16bit.wav": -23.0 LUFS (0.0 LU)
peak: -24.0 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[9/9] "seq-3341-7_seq-3342-5-24bit.wav": -23.0 LUFS (-0.0 LU)
peak: -8.9 TPFS, range: 4.8 LU
[ALBUM]: -23.2 LUFS (0.2 LU)
peak: -2.6 TPFS, range: 15.6 LU
done.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\3
analyzing ...
[1/4] "seq-3342-1-16bit.wav": -22.6 LUFS (-0.4 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 10.0 LU
[2/4] "seq-3342-2-16bit.wav": -16.8 LUFS (-6.2 LU)
peak: -15.0 TPFS, range: 5.0 LU
[3/4] "seq-3342-3-16bit.wav": -20.0 LUFS (-3.0 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 20.0 LU
[4/4] "seq-3342-4-16bit.wav": -24.5 LUFS (1.5 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 15.0 LU
[ALBUM]: -19.2 LUFS (-3.8 LU)
peak: -15.0 TPFS, range: 25.0 LU
done.
Done.
Hit enter to continue ...
R128GAIN v1.0.alpha6-2
DlgItemUrl sucessfully loaded.
SoX sucessfully loaded.
FFmpeg sucessfully loaded.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\1
analyzing ...
[1/3] "1kHz Sine -20 LUFS-16bit.wav": -20.6 LUFS (-2.4 LU)
peak: -19.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[2/3] "1kHz Sine -26 LUFS-16bit.wav": -26.6 LUFS (3.6 LU)
peak: -25.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[3/3] "1kHz Sine -40 LUFS-16bit.wav": -40.6 LUFS (17.6 LU)
peak: -39.8 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[ALBUM]: -22.6 LUFS (-0.4 LU)
peak: -19.9 TPFS, range: 20.0 LU
done.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\2
analyzing ...
[1/9] "seq-3341-1-16bit.wav": -23.6 LUFS (0.6 LU)
peak: -22.9 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[2/9] "seq-3341-2-16bit.wav": -33.6 LUFS (10.6 LU)
peak: -32.7 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[3/9] "seq-3341-2011-8_seq-3342-6-24bit-v02.wav": -21.9 LUFS (-1.1 LU)
peak: -2.6 TPFS, range: 17.7 LU
[4/9] "seq-3341-3-16bit-v02.wav": -23.4 LUFS (0.4 LU)
peak: -23.0 TPFS, range: 13.0 LU
[5/9] "seq-3341-4-16bit-v02.wav": -23.7 LUFS (0.7 LU)
peak: -23.0 TPFS, range: 13.0 LU
[6/9] "seq-3341-5-16bit-v02.wav": -23.6 LUFS (0.6 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 6.0 LU
[7/9] "seq-3341-6-5channels-16bit.wav": -23.2 LUFS (0.2 LU)
peak: -24.0 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[8/9] "seq-3341-6-6channels-WAVEEX-16bit.wav": -23.1 LUFS (0.1 LU)
peak: -24.0 TPFS, range: 0.0 LU
[9/9] "seq-3341-7_seq-3342-5-24bit.wav": -23.6 LUFS (0.6 LU)
peak: -8.9 TPFS, range: 4.7 LU
[ALBUM]: -23.0 LUFS (-0.0 LU)
peak: -2.6 TPFS, range: 16.2 LU
done.
E:\R128GAIN Test\0-EBU Loudness Test Set v03 (wav)\3
analyzing ...
[1/4] "seq-3342-1-16bit.wav": -23.2 LUFS (0.2 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 10.0 LU
[2/4] "seq-3342-2-16bit.wav": -17.5 LUFS (-5.5 LU)
peak: -15.0 TPFS, range: 5.0 LU
[3/4] "seq-3342-3-16bit.wav": -20.7 LUFS (-2.3 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 20.0 LU
[4/4] "seq-3342-4-16bit.wav": -25.2 LUFS (2.2 LU)
peak: -20.0 TPFS, range: 15.0 LU
[ALBUM]: -19.8 LUFS (-3.2 LU)
peak: -15.0 TPFS, range: 25.0 LU
done.
Done.
Hit enter to continue ...