HydrogenAudio

Lossy Audio Compression => MP3 => MP3 - General => Topic started by: geepondy on 2008-09-04 02:44:32

Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: geepondy on 2008-09-04 02:44:32
I have been ripping cds from dbpoweramp this evening and I get to "The Eagles Greatest Hits" and under the rip status, it says all ten tracks are "inaccurate".  What exactly does this mean?  I just listened to one of the ripped tracks and it sounds fine.
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: greynol on 2008-09-04 03:03:32
It just means that AccurateRip couldn't verify them.  So long as dBpa said they're secure and you haven't done anything to the settings to compromise security, then you should be ok.
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: ameliajune on 2008-09-05 01:57:40
I have been ripping cds from dbpoweramp this evening and I get to "The Eagles Greatest Hits" and under the rip status, it says all ten tracks are "inaccurate".  What exactly does this mean?  I just listened to one of the ripped tracks and it sounds fine.


I am perplexed on this myself, because I often get the insecure readings from dbpa (meaning there was something wrong) and they sound fine to me as well. Maybe my hearing is worse than I thought? 
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: spoon on 2008-09-05 13:51:39
Often errors are silenced out by the CD drive, there will be periods of silence, more errors = more silence where it becomes obvious. Many people think a rip is ok unless they hear loud pops.
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: bhoar on 2008-09-05 14:33:17
Just to reiterate what greynol said, if all tracks are listed as inaccurate, you may also have a different pressing that can't be validated against accuraterip.

-brendan
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: geepondy on 2008-09-06 00:54:57
I come across another entire cd that says it's inaccurate.  I assume if it was insecure, it would tell you this as well? Also what does the number in parenthesis mean after that rip whether it is accurate or inaccurate?
Title: What do the dbpoweramp rip status "inaccurate" statments mea
Post by: greynol on 2008-09-06 04:17:10
>I assume if it was insecure, it would tell you this as well?

Yes.

>what does the number in parenthesis mean after that rip whether it is accurate or inaccurate?

How many matches for the CRC (or one of the CRCs) it pulls up for your disc's id in the database.  Because you have a different pressing, the number is meaningless.