Skip to main content

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully (Read 8238 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

See attachment. Top half is 2.1.7's CUETools.Codecs.libFLAC.dll of 2018-03-12. Not even flac -0 is close to this bad.
Bottom half: the CUETools output recompressed using a more conventional 1.3.2.
High Voltage socket-nose-avatar

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #1
Doesn't look right. Weird. Thanks, i'll see if i can reproduce it.
CUETools 2.1.6

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #2
I can confirm. Also in 2.17,, when I compress album with libFLAC at -8, I get 285 MB. Cuetools FLAC compressor gives me 195 MB. Difference shouldn't be so big.
Compressed with flac 1.3.2, I get 196 MB.
Error 404; signature server not available.

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #3
I'm not reproducing the problem so far (but I only ran a few tests).

libflac -8 212MB
cuetools -8 212MB
flac.exe 1.3.2 -8 212MB (CLI)

ibflac -8 414MB
cuetools -8 413MB
flac.exe 1.3.2 -8 413MB (CLI)
korth

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #4
If instructions sets matter: SSE 4.1 and 4.2 and AVX2 (an aged Intel i3) on 64-bit Windows 7.
High Voltage socket-nose-avatar

 

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #5
I have problem at work - big differences in compression ratio. There I have windows 8.1 64bit, and i7-4790. At home, no problems, Windows 10 64 bit, i7-2600. Same portable installation, shared through Mega cloud.
Error 404; signature server not available.

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #6
Got the chance to test another computer and reproduce it.
i5-6200U running Windows 10.
Same results as above.

But it is fast!
High Voltage socket-nose-avatar

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #7
I guess it's AVX2 or AVX512 support that's awfully fast, but awful compression ratio, too.

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #8
replace libFLAC_dynamic.dll with version from e.g. Rarewares and test again?

Also, please upload a short sample somewhere.

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #9
4 second FLAC attached. If that is too little, I can upload more.
820 kbit/sec.
Other FLAC 1.3.2 at -8: 560. Including, the DLL found at 2018-11-16 from http://www.rarewares.org/lossless.php#flac-dll-x64 under the headline "libFLAC v.1.3.2 incorporating GIT updates to 2018-11-16 for win64".
Replacing the DLL makes it work just fine, thanks for that quick fix.

(For the love of CUETools, I picked one where it managed to fix twenty-thousand rip-errors in these <4 seconds. CUETools repaired this for me.)


Edit: got the attachment right.
High Voltage socket-nose-avatar

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #10
The command
Code: [Select]
flac -a "Matthäuspassion cuetools-libFLAC_dynamic-x64 ¤¤ 01 ¤¤¤ 50a. Recitative -Evangelist; Sie schrieen aber noch mehr.flac"
shows that this file has too many VERBATIM frames, but honestly, I have no idea why.

Re: CUETools 2.1.7's libflac compresses awfully

Reply #11
26 VERBATIM out of 2x42 FLAC subframes. Ordinary FLAC has none.
Not that I know the FLAC format, but if a VERBATIM subframe makes for uncompressed size 1411, the remaining 84-26 subframes wouldn't be far from the 560 that should have been the average.

I tried the same for another low-bitrate file (Epica: Supremacy) and could find that no VERBATIM for ordinary FLAC turned into 1 in 8.

Then on the other end of the bitrate scale: Merzbow: Ananga-Ranga, which clocks in at 1329 kb/s with ordinary FLAC, and 1412 with CUETools. (Yes, it is CDDA.) 37520 FLAC subframes (yes, half an hour). type=VERBATIM count:
5102 for ordinary FLAC. 37439 for CUETools FLAC
Even worse bitrate, same album, I Lead You Towards Glorious Times, which with ordinary FLAC reaches 1395 and CUETools needs 1412. 7102 subframes.
Ordinary FLAC:  7098 FIXED, 4 VERBATIM
CUETools FLAC: 2 FIXED, 7094 VERBATIM, 6 LPC
High Voltage socket-nose-avatar

 
SimplePortal 1.0.0 RC1 © 2008-2021