I wish one day ...
Reply #14 – 2006-08-28 08:16:34
Maybe it's just Middle-east politics, but that whole area doesn't seem to value human life much at all. That's the generalization I was getting at. And the generalization is so obviously false that there is no point in arguing about it. But I have some time. I dunno; my knowledge of history is quite limited here, and that's one of the reasons I was posing these questions. I do, however, have a rather intimate knowledge of the religion involved. You cannot have an intimate knowledge of Islam without having an intimate knowledge of it's history and of the history of the Middle east.realize there are gray areas, but when Arabs start coming up with political parties that call themselves the "Party of God" (Hizballah) and advocate the killing of others, I start to get frightened. Combine that with the current unity of church and state in Iran, a situation that Western society knows from experience to be flawed... Hey, I believe in the US they have organisations like the KKK, NRA and a lot of wacky Christian movements. Should I therefor condemn every US citizen as racist, or whatever?I'm also considering Arab-Islamic interpretation of law, and the massive human rights violations against women that were occurring in Afghanistan even before the invasion (it hasn't helped much). The existence of human rights in the west (certainly that of women and minorities) are something of the last 50 (maybe even less) years (remember Martin L. King, remember South-Africa?). And right now, women are still not considered equal to men (check their salaries in equal jobs). And you want them to make the step that is taking us for so long already (and mind you a step that we still have not fully taken), just in a few months? It is not going to happen.There's the current situation in Iraq, where Sunnis and Shiites are killing each other over obscure eschatological differences that don't have any grounding in reality outside of Qur'anic interpretation... Hey, let's take a look at Northern-Ireland for a moment, reminds you of something? Hmmm...Finally, the nail in the coffin (IMO) is the low level of Muslim condemnation of this behaviour. Why should a muslim feel responsible for what a few idiots who call themselves muslims do? Why do we blame a group of hundreds of million people for what a minority is doing? If we cannot bring ourselves to see the difference, then perhaps we are not yet as civilized as you think.