HydrogenAudio

Lossy Audio Compression => Ogg Vorbis => Ogg Vorbis - Tech => Topic started by: BananaHat on 2008-08-08 03:21:50

Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: BananaHat on 2008-08-08 03:21:50
Hello,

a few years back, I heard (somewhere :-S) of a feature that would theoretically make it possible to encode to Ogg Vorbis in such a way that one could later "transcode" it to a lower bitrate without recoding but instead just taking some chunks. (i.e. originally encode with -q 5 and then do the magic to end up with -q 3 in a very fast and (computationally) inexpensive way)

Does anybody know what this feature is called and it's current status? (Back then, there was just talk that it would be theoretically possible with one certain encoder implementation, but no plans were made to implement it (yet))

Thanks!

P.S: Yes, I searched for it quite extensively, but alas it just won't "click" :-S
Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: kjoonlee on 2008-08-08 03:24:16
It was called peeling, but it would have required a special encoder. Nobody was willing to write a special encoder, though.
Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: BananaHat on 2008-08-08 03:46:31
It was called peeling, but it would have required a special encoder.
Nobody was willing to write a special encoder, though.
Thank you so much for this blazing fast reply
It's a pitty; but maybe someday... *humming* "dream on, dream on"...
Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: saivert on 2008-09-02 23:16:57
Sort of like MP3pro/HE-AAC without the SBR information (you can strip it) then.
or Monkeys Audio hybrid compression mode.
Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: Tahnru on 2008-09-02 23:25:53
Sort of like MP3pro/HE-AAC without the SBR information (you can strip it) then.
or Monkeys Audio hybrid compression mode.


Whoa, Monkey's has a hybrid compression mode?  I didn't know that.
Title: "onion" bitrates
Post by: pdq on 2008-09-02 23:35:01
Sort of like MP3pro/HE-AAC without the SBR information (you can strip it) then.
or Monkeys Audio hybrid compression mode.

Not really. Both of those codecs played back without the sbr information aren't that much smaller, but sound a lot worse. Bit peeling would have given gradually lower quality while steadily reducing size. At least that was the promise.