Does Heavy Metal sound bad or is it my speakers?
Reply #89 – 2015-02-07 19:27:45
Maybe the opposite is true, because he likes metal he's annoyed by bad sound quality. I just don't like the statement, because it implies that a quarter of my music collection is of abysmal quality, i.e. utter garbage. That, in turn, sounds like snobbery. What's wrong with that statement? It's not a personal attack. A good portion of music I really, really like is of abysmal sound quality. I sometimes fantasize how it would sound if it had not been touched by Vlado Meller and his cohort. Seriously, because I like it I'm even more appalled by shoddy production. Having bought a better pair of headphones made the situation even worse. Maybe listening with speakers again and a good sub like Arny suggests help. But then again hearing ability changes over time, too (no offense to Arny), so my preference might change, too. Apparently all the audiophool old people like the same horrible masters in "hi-res" now, though they didn't like when they were released on CD. I just want to know what is considered 'bad quality'. Is it the distortion due to excessive peak limiting? Is it some sort of DRC? Is it EQ applied? Is it the balance between different instruments that isn't right? Except the first one, those are really a matter of taste. The usual suspects, bad EQ, tremendous amounts of DRC and clipping, and in turn general loudness. Some (CD-era production) albums I have hardly have 10 bits of dynamic range (as tested by inspecting dropped bits in LossyWav), with really weird choices in the EQ department. More generally, anything which doesn't sound like a real band playing instruments (on albums where this was most certainly the aim), anything without dynamics, or anything where instruments are completely swamped in noise is bad sound quality to me. Metal (and friends) has a plethora of examples, Meshuggah, Metallica, Lamb of God, Mastodon, System of a Down, etc. But I don't really see the point of mentioning examples, because certainly there are very bad examples, and some good examples. Maybe you are lucky because you like the good ones, or you're just not annoyed by stuff other think to be a deficiency. That's fine, I mean you said it yourself:These songs never fail to excite me, which is in the end, what this music is about for me. Sometimes I wished I could be happier again listening to RHCP or The Mars Volta.