Skip to main content

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: Best Compression Format/Codec (Read 4108 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Best Compression Format/Codec

Hi, I am new at encoding large audio files [wav] into compressed audio format.  I've always been using MP3 as my codecs but I've seen many other ones pop up lately and do not know which is which.  Can anyone help me and explain which codec will yield the best audio quality if everything is on maximum setting?  What I mean is that say if you have a WMA file at maximum setting versus an MP3 file at maximum setting (320kbps I think), how does each different codecs compare against one another?  Thanks for all the help.

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #1
Lame with freeformat settings @640KBPS

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #2
@ara-fat32: We help people on this board not make fun of them.

If you care for the best quality no matter what the bitrate is try one of the lossless codecs, they have no quality loss (that is why the term lossless) compared to the original. That's the best you can get.

If you are willing to sacrifice some quality (which is usually inaudible) for a gain in space then check out the lossy codecs: MP3/Vorbis/MPC/AAC.
Very basically put:
MP3: The standard, best hardware support, older standard.
Vorbis: Free/Open codec as good as MP3. Less hardware support.
AAC: Successor to MP3 pushed by big corporations. High quality. Lossy format of the future.
MPC: Generally highest quality you can get at high bitrates. Very high encoding/decoding speed. Minimal hardware support (You can play on your PC though).

Try to do a search and do a bit of reading. The information is there.
The object of mankind lies in its highest individuals.
One must have chaos in oneself to be able to give birth to a dancing star.

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #3
Maby the FAQ would have some information that would intrest you.

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #4
Quote
What I mean is that say if you have a WMA file at maximum setting versus an MP3 file at maximum setting (320kbps I think), how does each different codecs compare against one another?


At such high birates I doubt you'd be able to tell any of the lossy codecs apart.  ABX'ing at that point is really really hard.
Nero AAC 1.5.1.0: -q0.45

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #5
one factor in choosing between lossly and lossless can be the source and intended use of the resulting files. If CDs are the source then lossy may very well be fine; personally most of my work involves tape or vinyls and I use lossless (FLAC) to avoid having to repeat the transfer process in the future. Always a simple matter to transcode to whatever lossy codec of choice.

 

Best Compression Format/Codec

Reply #6
atici : 3rd paragr. 'lossless' -> 'lossy' ;)
(maybe are you making fun of us ?...)
Newborn MPC, Matroska and Foobar enthusiast.
Thanks to all the authors and developers =)