Dial-up bitrate listening test
Reply #122 – 2004-06-29 20:28:54
Hi, just a few reminders. Dialup modems using v.90 can't send faster than 33.6kbps. v.92 allows a tiny little bit more if line conditions allow, something like 40kbps. For .v9x to work, there needs to be a digital isdn like thingie at the other end (eg. ISP), otherwise you are stuck at v.34 (33.6kbps max bi-dir). It is not uncommon for modems to throttle down when line noise increases. You also have to accomodate for protocol overhead (v.xx+ppp+tcp, etc). There is a little help with the use of realtime lzw compression (around 4:1 for text). On the other hand, too many people nowdays use softmodems, which tie the cpu since the whole modulation demodulation is done in software. This cause too many unexpected issues, be lucky if it works at all.. So i think 32kbps should be the maximun intended bitrate for dialup modems. Some people may get thru with a little more, but not all. In fact, sometimes establishing a 33.6kbps link can be difficult, 31.2, 28.8 and 26.4 are not uncommon connect rates. Also, i am one of those people who favored ogg vorbis instead of speex for mostly speech based content. After many tests, my reasoning is this: Yes, for the same bitrate, the speech codecs can make the voice sound better, BUT, add something else in the content (hand clap, second voice, instruments, street noise, etc, etc, etc), and a major artifact will come, often distorting the main voice. When using a non speech codec, it may have an overall reduced quality, but this quality tends to remain stable (ie, not suddendly adding very annoying artifacts). With Ogg Vorbis, streaming an AM radio (live) just using -q-1 and --resample 8000 (mono) i get a very listenable landline telephone like quality, averaging around 9kbps with peaks never exceeding 12kbps. I have set up a test stream you can access here (spanish language) http://mipagina.cantv.net/artemis3/radio/ I understand this is not the fault of the speech codecs, they were just intended for other things. This will be an interesting test, and most ppl can participate