HydrogenAudio

Hosted Forums => foobar2000 => Support - (fb2k) => Topic started by: Manolo on 2017-03-27 11:21:33

Title: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: Manolo on 2017-03-27 11:21:33
Hi all,

I use Foobar2000 as my default music player (v1.3.14). I recorded a part of the rhythm guitar of Ho, Hey from Lumineers to help a friend playing it and when I listen it throught Foobar2000, I hear some kind of flanger (it's subtle but you can hear it well at the end of the mp3) and I tried with other players : VLC, Groove, in Firefox and I even downloaded MusicBee to be sure and it does this only in Foobar AND this mp3 (or the original wav file).

It's the first time I hear something like.

Not a big deal but it's always a good thing to understand why it does this :).
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: dhromed on 2017-03-27 12:21:44
Can't hear anything odd, just a smooth decay with a tiny cutoff after the last strum.

Plugins? DSPs? Output mode?
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: darkflame23 on 2017-03-27 13:16:12
Sounds normal here too. If it's only happening in FB2K then you likely have some FX switched on, or some 'behind the scenes' SRC is going on maybe?
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: Manolo on 2017-03-27 14:36:13
Thanks for replies. I also asked my self about plugins or something else but it happens only to this file. I tried the mp3 file on an other PC and it sounds ok so it seems it's something very specific to my main PC, this file and Foobar2000.

I recorded with a mic in front of speakers the end of the file where it's more obvious (at 8") what I hear from Foobar2000.
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: darkflame23 on 2017-03-27 17:26:54
Sounds like wow and flutter from a dodgy tape deck.
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: j7n on 2017-03-27 18:43:23
I hear a thud after each of the last notes at approximately 7.05s and 8.25s, and then again similarly sounding steps during the fadeout: d-d-d-d. These sounds attract my attention because they sound like repaired clicks or sudden jumps in level. With the volume raised, these sounds indeed change into "wows" and seem less annoying. I don't know if this is to be expected from a microphone in front of the speaker. They aren't present in the original clip.
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: Manolo on 2017-03-28 09:51:16
I don't know if this is to be expected from a microphone in front of the speaker. They aren't present in the original clip.

It's what I hear, the mic in front of speaker just recorded it ;). As it's very specific, I think the topic can be marked as "Solved".
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: dhromed on 2017-03-28 13:58:55
It's even clearly visible in the spectrogram, see image.
In yours as well? It's still a mystery why playing in foobar produces this wobble. Could be an effect set in windows or your sound card.
Title: Re: Some kind of flanger on a mp3 (file provided)
Post by: Manolo on 2017-03-28 16:45:09
It's not an effect set in Windows or my soundcard (which has no effects by the way) cause it happens only on this mp3. It remains some of mystery of computers :P.