Few days ago I've bougth a used Iron Maiden Cd, it was not in a very good state of conservation, with many scratches. After some cleaning I tried to rip it with EAC, the resulting log says:
Exact Audio Copy V1.0 beta 3 from 29. August 2011
EAC extraction logfile from 22. November 2012, 8:57
Iron Maiden / Killers
Used drive : ATAPI DVD A DH16ABSH Adapter: 0 ID: 1
Read mode : Burst
Read offset correction : 6
Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out : No
Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes
Delete leading and trailing silent blocks : No
Null samples used in CRC calculations : Yes
Used interface : Native Win32 interface for Win NT & 2000
Used output format : User Defined Encoder
Selected bitrate : 32 kBit/s
Quality : High
Add ID3 tag : No
Command line compressor : C:\Program Files (x86)\foobar2000\flac.exe
Additional command line options : -5 %source%
TOC of the extracted CD
Track | Start | Length | Start sector | End sector
---------------------------------------------------------
1 | 0:00.32 | 1:45.63 | 32 | 7969
2 | 1:46.20 | 2:54.30 | 7970 | 21049
3 | 4:40.50 | 4:18.22 | 21050 | 40421
4 | 8:58.72 | 3:22.73 | 40422 | 55644
5 | 12:21.70 | 3:07.05 | 55645 | 69674
6 | 15:29.00 | 3:52.32 | 69675 | 87106
7 | 19:21.32 | 5:00.65 | 87107 | 109671
8 | 24:22.22 | 6:12.20 | 109672 | 137591
9 | 30:34.42 | 3:20.05 | 137592 | 152596
10 | 33:54.47 | 4:48.50 | 152597 | 174246
Range status and errors
Selected range
Filename G:\Musik\Iron Maiden - 1981 - Killers\Iron Maiden - 1981 - Killers.wav
Timing problem 0:00:07
Timing problem 0:00:12 - 0:00:14
Timing problem 0:00:16 - 0:00:17
Timing problem 0:03:43
Timing problem 0:04:36
Timing problem 0:04:45 - 0:04:48
Timing problem 0:04:57 - 0:05:00
Timing problem 0:05:02 - 0:05:08
Timing problem 0:05:51
Timing problem 0:06:06
Timing problem 0:06:16
Timing problem 0:06:18
Timing problem 0:06:21
Timing problem 0:06:25 - 0:06:26
Timing problem 0:06:36 - 0:06:37
Timing problem 0:06:39
Timing problem 0:06:41
Timing problem 0:06:43
Timing problem 0:06:45 - 0:06:49
Timing problem 0:06:51
Timing problem 0:06:58 - 0:06:59
Timing problem 0:07:30
Timing problem 0:08:54
Timing problem 0:09:29 - 0:09:33
Timing problem 0:09:39 - 0:09:55
Timing problem 0:09:59
Timing problem 0:10:03 - 0:10:13
Timing problem 0:10:15
Timing problem 0:10:21
Timing problem 0:10:24
Timing problem 0:10:30 - 0:10:31
Timing problem 0:10:36
Timing problem 0:11:57
Timing problem 0:11:59 - 0:12:05
Timing problem 0:12:07 - 0:12:08
Timing problem 0:12:11
Timing problem 0:12:13 - 0:12:21
Timing problem 0:12:26 - 0:12:29
Timing problem 0:13:11 - 0:13:32
Timing problem 0:13:45 - 0:13:57
Timing problem 0:14:01
Timing problem 0:14:03 - 0:14:07
Timing problem 0:14:09 - 0:14:12
Timing problem 0:14:34
Timing problem 0:15:18
Timing problem 0:15:22 - 0:15:34
Timing problem 0:15:36 - 0:15:44
Timing problem 0:15:46 - 0:15:49
Timing problem 0:15:55
Timing problem 0:15:57 - 0:15:58
Timing problem 0:16:00 - 0:16:01
Timing problem 0:16:03 - 0:16:04
Timing problem 0:16:07 - 0:16:10
Timing problem 0:16:15 - 0:16:21
Timing problem 0:16:24
Timing problem 0:16:30
Timing problem 0:16:32 - 0:16:42
Timing problem 0:16:48 - 0:16:49
Timing problem 0:16:51
Timing problem 0:16:58
Timing problem 0:17:36 - 0:17:46
Timing problem 0:18:29
Timing problem 0:18:31 - 0:18:32
Timing problem 0:18:58 - 0:19:05
Timing problem 0:19:11 - 0:19:12
Timing problem 0:19:15
Timing problem 0:19:20
Timing problem 0:19:22
Timing problem 0:19:42
Timing problem 0:19:46
Timing problem 0:19:56
Timing problem 0:19:58 - 0:20:01
Timing problem 0:20:43 - 0:20:48
Timing problem 0:20:50 - 0:20:51
Timing problem 0:20:53
Timing problem 0:21:27
Timing problem 0:22:38
Timing problem 0:22:50 - 0:22:52
Timing problem 0:22:54 - 0:22:55
Timing problem 0:22:57
Timing problem 0:23:08
Timing problem 0:23:16 - 0:23:17
Timing problem 0:23:19
Timing problem 0:23:21 - 0:23:23
Timing problem 0:23:27
Timing problem 0:23:29
Timing problem 0:23:31
Timing problem 0:23:35 - 0:23:36
Timing problem 0:23:39 - 0:23:41
Timing problem 0:24:23
Timing problem 0:24:27
Timing problem 0:24:34
Timing problem 0:24:39
Timing problem 0:25:01
Timing problem 0:25:04 - 0:25:06
Timing problem 0:25:08
Timing problem 0:26:21
Timing problem 0:26:26
Timing problem 0:26:30 - 0:26:31
Timing problem 0:28:06
Timing problem 0:28:21
Timing problem 0:28:23
Timing problem 0:28:27
Timing problem 0:28:38 - 0:28:43
Timing problem 0:29:26 - 0:29:31
Timing problem 0:29:33
Timing problem 0:29:35
Timing problem 0:29:37 - 0:29:38
Timing problem 0:29:41 - 0:29:43
Timing problem 0:29:46 - 0:29:58
Timing problem 0:30:00 - 0:30:05
Timing problem 0:30:08 - 0:30:11
Timing problem 0:30:13 - 0:30:15
Timing problem 0:30:17 - 0:30:35
Timing problem 0:31:18 - 0:31:19
Timing problem 0:31:21 - 0:31:22
Timing problem 0:31:26 - 0:31:27
Timing problem 0:31:32 - 0:31:34
Timing problem 0:31:36 - 0:31:37
Timing problem 0:32:19
Timing problem 0:32:24
Timing problem 0:32:44
Timing problem 0:33:42 - 0:38:42
Peak level 99.7 %
Extraction speed 2.8 X
Test CRC E435686A
Copy CRC 46EA545C
Copy finished
No errors occurred
AccurateRip summary
Track 1 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 70) [45915099], AccurateRip returned [AB545ECE] (AR v2)
Track 2 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 70) [43D94978], AccurateRip returned [03286E74] (AR v2)
Track 3 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 70) [70407142], AccurateRip returned [C1BD2C64] (AR v2)
Track 4 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [C11EBAA2], AccurateRip returned [19C240DB] (AR v2)
Track 5 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [7B6D6652], AccurateRip returned [16F79A4F] (AR v2)
Track 6 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [FE39B5E1], AccurateRip returned [89378EE9] (AR v2)
Track 7 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [BC05E306], AccurateRip returned [BB29522F] (AR v2)
Track 8 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [576E524E], AccurateRip returned [49BBA1C1] (AR v2)
Track 9 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 69) [B35D814D], AccurateRip returned [4F5DCCDB] (AR v2)
Track 10 cannot be verified as accurate (confidence 68) [87E2CEB4], AccurateRip returned [2F26BC22] (AR v2)
No tracks could be verified as accurate
You may have a different pressing from the one(s) in the database
End of status report
---- CUETools DB Plugin V2.1.3
[CTDB TOCID: x0EG7SCcp_M0cPDj7jbwzYVQHns-] found, Submit result: discs with pregaps not supported in this protocol version
[fe1a93dc] (162/162) No match
Obviously there were problems in reading the data correctly (timing problems, mismatching crc, failed accuraterip verification), but how shall I interpret the information given by eac: "No errors occurred"?
Many thanks, if someone could help me!
Harald
From the EAC (http://www.exactaudiocopy.de/en/index.php/support/faq/extraction-questions/) site:
Question: When using burst mode, EAC also shows up timing problems, are these really errors or what?
Answer: No, burst mode has no error detection nor error correction. If burst mode brings up a timing problem, the read command needed a lot of time, which could have several reasons, like loosing sync or trying to fix an read error. Of course this is a really poor “error detection” and should not be taken as serious indication.
Did you try using a 'secure' mode?
Iron Maiden / Killers
Well I don't think Killers was ever re-released with that pesky copy protection.
From the EAC (http://www.exactaudiocopy.de/en/index.php/support/faq/extraction-questions/) site:
Question: When using burst mode, EAC also shows up timing problems, are these really errors or what?
Answer: No, burst mode has no error detection nor error correction. If burst mode brings up a timing problem, the read command needed a lot of time, which could have several reasons, like loosing sync or trying to fix an read error. Of course this is a really poor “error detection” and should not be taken as serious indication.
Did you try using a 'secure' mode?
2nd that.
Clearly my fault, I had to think about that!
Tried to rip the CD in secure mode, it took more than three hours for ripping 10 minutes of the album, then I aborted the operation. I suppose the Cd is so damaged, that an accurate reading is impossible.
Thanks fpr your kind help!
Harald
::
... and you might want to use the latest CTDB Plugin (http://www.cuetools.net/wiki/CTDB_EAC_Plugin) with Exact Audio Copy ...
Regards, ...
::