My results:
ABC/HR Version 0.9b, 30 August 2002
Testname: ATRAC TYPE-R / ATRAC3+ Hi-SP / MP3 LAME / VORBIS / MPC Comparison
1R = castanets hi-sp.wav
2L = castanets mpc.wav
3L = castanets mp3.wav
4R = castanets ogg.wav
5L = castanets sp.wav
---------------------------------------
General Comments:
---------------------------------------
1R File: castanets hi-sp.wav
1R Rating: 1.0
1R Comment: First guitar note is strangely smeared. Annoying.
Castanets are awful: very agressive, with bad, "electric" noise. It sounds clearly worse than pre-echo to my ears.
0.0 /5.0 is a more realistic note.
---------------------------------------
2L File: castanets mpc.wav
2L Rating: 3.7
2L Comment: "piou-piou" sound, typical artifact of mpc with this sample
---------------------------------------
3L File: castanets mp3.wav
3L Rating: 1.8
3L Comment: like 1R, first guitar note is completely smeared. Castanets are smeared when isolated (0.6 - 1.5), but are then ~ok.
---------------------------------------
4R File: castanets ogg.wav
4R Rating: 4.0
4R Comment:
---------------------------------------
5L File: castanets sp.wav
5L Rating: 2.3
5L Comment: first guitar note is smeared, but also distorted and unatural. Apparently, there's a stereo problem: there's a moving noise, really audible on the right channel during this first note. Weird...
Castenets suffer from an audible loss in sharpness, and they sound dull, synthetic.
---------------------------------------
ABX Results:
Original vs castanets hi-sp.wav
16 out of 16, pval < 0.001
Original vs castanets mpc.wav
14 out of 16, pval = 0.002
Original vs castanets mp3.wav
16 out of 16, pval < 0.001
Original vs castanets ogg.wav
9 out of 16, pval = 0.402
Original vs castanets sp.wav
16 out of 16, pval < 0.001
Note that I failed to ABX vorbis megamixII with this sample (on a quick-ABX test). It's in my opinion the only encoder free of artifact (it doesn't necessary mean free of distortion). Atrac3plus is nice as low-anchor; old-Atrac is much better, though it's not really good on this sample (artifacted, smeared and also synthetic).
Anyway Kouby, thanks for creating and uploading this DDD sample of an atrac recording. Other samples are really welcome