Skip to main content

Topic: CUETools DB (Read 171544 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
  • korth
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #175
CT was then able to recognize the disc, but still wouldn't do a repair.

The recovery record can only repair a limited amount of damage. Your rip likely exceeds that amount of damage.
  • Last Edit: 30 December, 2012, 09:32:04 AM by korth
korth

  • Eli
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #176
CT was then able to recognize the disc, but still wouldn't do a repair.

The recovery record can only repair a limited amount of damage. Your rip likely exceeds that amount of damage.


Korth, you are probably right. I wish CT would tell you something to that effect...

  • lvqcl
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Developer
CUETools DB
Reply #177
http://www.cuetools.net/wiki/CUETools_log

Accurately ripped -- Your rip matches database records for this track
Differs in ... -- Partial match this track, might be repairable
No match -- Too many samples differ

  • ebz777
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #178
Add Chromaprint and AcoustID relationships within CUETools DB

Hello Gregory,
The CUETools DB is already cross-referencing at the CD TOC level the freedb and MusicBrainz databases.
Would you also consider doing this at the tracklevel with Chromaprint fingerprints and AcoustIDs (see http://acoustid.org/) ?

This would help the match of an individual track to a release, regardless of any later lossy re-encoding. This is something you cannot do with the current CUETools DB tracks CRCs alone : there is now way to calculate that proper CRC for an mp3 track for example. The only way to ensure a consistent fingerprint calculation for a CD release is at ripping time.

It would require to calculate the chromaprint fingerprint for every tracked ripped with CUERipper and add these references to CUETtools DB.
I'm not sure though that CUETools DB should also link the AcoustID; the fingerprint -> AcoustID assignment process is still very far from perfect (see http://forums.musicbrainz.org/viewtopic.php?id=3869). But it could be considered safe, there is no plan to merge AcoustID I believe and it would be a nice bonus !

Maybe CUERipper/CUETools could then also publish the calculated Chromaprint fingerprints to the AcoustID DB (see http://acoustid.org/webservice#submit)

Additionally CUETools could then also tag the tracks it generates with the AcoustID

Thanks

  • bilbo
  • [*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #179
Add Chromaprint and AcoustID relationships within CUETools DB
This would help the match of an individual track to a release, regardless of any later lossy re-encoding.


CUEToolsDB is meant to verify and/or repair rips from a CD. Why would anyone want to verify a "lossy" track? That is the opposite of what the DB was designed to accomplish.
Glass half full!

  • ebz777
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #180
CUEToolsDB is meant to verify and/or repair rips from a CD. Why would anyone want to verify a "lossy" track?


Yes, the data correction made ??during a rip is what motivates a large number of users to publish their information in the database in the first place. But once the information is out there it is metadata that can be used for purposes that were not originally intended. Eg to identify similar recordings from different releases, to find out what recordings exactly are included in a compilation. To identify whether a particular release includes the original or remastered version of a recording. Or in the presence of a piece of music lossy you want to tag, to know what CD this song was coming from.

This is something that you cannot do with the track CRC calculated today, but that you could do if you add a fingerprint calculation to the track.

It's of course best calculated at rip time since it's the surest way to ensure consistency between a CD and its track information.

CUETools DB
Reply #181
It doesn't seem very fair - people that would be wasting their CPU cycles to calculate those fingerprints would be helping a completely different category of users to identify random mp3s.
CUETools 2.1.4

  • Eli
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #182
CueTools 2.1.5

I am trying to repair a disc
The Rolling Stones
Exile on Main St.
CTDB TOCID: kXCUmR9eH1zJRjVprT_Hvhp_Kzc-

I am able to verify the disc fine:
Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 6/3/2013 8:46:47 PM; Version: 2.1.5]
[CTDB TOCID: kXCUmR9eH1zJRjVprT_Hvhp_Kzc-] found.
Track | CTDB Status
  1  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
  2  | (41/41) Accurately ripped
  3  | (41/41) Accurately ripped
  4  | (41/41) Accurately ripped
  5  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
  6  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
  7  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
  8  | (39/41) Accurately ripped
  9  | (39/41) Accurately ripped
 10  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
 11  | (40/41) Accurately ripped
 12  | (38/41) Accurately ripped
 13  | (38/41) Accurately ripped
 14  | (39/41) Accurately ripped
 15  | (31/41) Differs in 35 samples @00:13:31-00:13:32
 16  | (37/41) Accurately ripped
 17  | (35/41) Accurately ripped
 18  | (36/41) Accurately ripped
[AccurateRip ID: 002ab05f-023b7e5b-f50fc512] found.
Track  [  CRC  |  V2  ] Status
 01    [3d93162a|cd2757b3] (074+003/349) Accurately ripped
 02    [7c634221|95c2e2e1] (073+003/349) Accurately ripped
 03    [23d503ed|98b85eef] (074+003/355) Accurately ripped
 04    [3f1e5129|d771c8fa] (074+003/349) Accurately ripped
 05    [c8227004|8192ee79] (075+003/355) Accurately ripped
 06    [7e1afc91|8565f83f] (074+003/349) Accurately ripped
 07    [895203b2|735c7815] (073+003/349) Accurately ripped
 08    [47598ba8|ead177ad] (073+003/351) Accurately ripped
 09    [479220a6|8ace56d1] (072+003/347) Accurately ripped
 10    [4db31259|7bf5c4c3] (072+003/347) Accurately ripped
 11    [3eaf488d|1039e7ef] (072+003/346) Accurately ripped
 12    [fb309295|5e3a4f6b] (072+003/347) Accurately ripped
 13    [1d9e8a7c|25010632] (072+003/338) Accurately ripped
 14    [6ef1796d|ea98ffaa] (072+003/336) Accurately ripped
 15    [d781ac36|6768463e] (000+000/338) No match
 16    [bd9a1da4|6ab7466d] (071+003/334) Accurately ripped
 17    [c2e9e1c4|275f2638] (073+003/330) Accurately ripped
 18    [0c2fb6e7|39781207] (070+003/321) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 76:
 01    [009fb622] (002/349) Accurately ripped
 02    [d23367ae] (002/349) Accurately ripped
 03    [159aef17] (002/355) Accurately ripped
 04    [53d16027] (002/349) Accurately ripped
 05    [554d3116] (002/355) Accurately ripped
 06    [cb2c24b8] (000/349) No match (V2 was not tested)
 07    [bab54b8d] (000/349) No match (V2 was not tested)
 08    [b278672a] (002/351) Accurately ripped
 09    [2420d59e] (002/347) Accurately ripped
 10    [aef143b6] (002/347) Accurately ripped
 11    [021e8ecb] (002/346) Accurately ripped
 12    [bf03a663] (002/347) Accurately ripped
 13    [c032788c] (002/338) Accurately ripped
 14    [fe7c9eb5] (002/336) Accurately ripped
 15    [69ee3f21] (000/338) No match (V2 was not tested)
 16    [4b96ee3b] (002/334) Accurately ripped
 17    [67b38275] (002/330) Accurately ripped
 18    [d1be152e] (000/321) No match (V2 was not tested)
Offsetted by 664:
 01    [a26e64a2] (168/349) Accurately ripped
 02    [f17cd341] (169/349) Accurately ripped
 03    [9fb7d390] (172/355) Accurately ripped
 04    [4ed38139] (168/349) Accurately ripped
 05    [a89fd22b] (175/355) Accurately ripped
 06    [fd29d425] (170/349) Accurately ripped
 07    [6e12aace] (169/349) Accurately ripped
 08    [38ac53d6] (169/351) Accurately ripped
 09    [ddfd4d89] (165/347) Accurately ripped
 10    [6db7a9a5] (168/347) Accurately ripped
 11    [ac16c55d] (167/346) Accurately ripped
 12    [f6515282] (171/347) Accurately ripped
 13    [0c33b759] (163/338) Accurately ripped
 14    [0092fdb4] (164/336) Accurately ripped
 15    [b2b9c150] (000/338) No match (V2 was not tested)
 16    [df81134e] (161/334) Accurately ripped
 17    [aed29e8e] (161/330) Accurately ripped
 18    [8d45be26] (154/321) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 2140:
 01    [83ed544a] (075/349) Accurately ripped
 02    [12537512] (075/349) Accurately ripped
 03    [14c5cc55] (077/355) Accurately ripped
 04    [7366a48e] (075/349) Accurately ripped
 05    [159973ef] (073/355) Accurately ripped
 06    [f3b1b8a4] (075/349) Accurately ripped
 07    [a17d3ef2] (077/349) Accurately ripped
 08    [c8d95ab6] (077/351) Accurately ripped
 09    [4e49411f] (078/347) Accurately ripped
 10    [8d8409be] (075/347) Accurately ripped
 11    [f7ada841] (075/346) Accurately ripped
 12    [da86fb24] (072/347) Accurately ripped
 13    [de6ab9b4] (071/338) Accurately ripped
 14    [dd314f57] (070/336) Accurately ripped
 15    [b6ea7a75] (000/338) No match (V2 was not tested)
 16    [365fdba9] (072/334) Accurately ripped
 17    [93a1fc6f] (068/330) Accurately ripped
 18    [f510276c] (065/321) Accurately ripped

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL]
 --  97.7 [F215327F] [561E67E0]         
 01  97.7 [FEB5E1BA] [81AB5674]         
 02  97.7 [A42C7CAD] [ADBFE045]         
 03  84.7 [B2486164] [57A64BDD]         
 04  97.7 [D31DB1EE] [89BD4C76]         
 05  97.7 [72F66D51] [E62C37D4]         
 06  97.7 [43EFFACF] [06A347A2]         
 07  97.7 [46B24C6F] [AF099ACD]         
 08  97.7 [47EBA0D1] [805EC507]         
 09  97.7 [EDBA4CEE] [0AF13865]         
 10  97.7 [8E17B700] [E1C62A3A]         
 11  85.9 [A621CDE9] [98631D15]         
 12  97.7 [A49DD7DF] [1FAECAD8]         
 13  86.9 [B76795DB] [C446C48B]         
 14  97.7 [4FF15683] [D2788406]         
 15  97.7 [D0E72E22] [9BA021C4]         
 16  97.7 [97D1D4D9] [F0E89505]         
 17  97.7 [61BF4321] [3A1119E0]         
 18  97.7 [00E9D0D0] [B2DA7473]         

But when I try to repair, I get an error that says

"Unsupported Encoder Settings"

I have been able to repair other discs with 2.1.5, also encoded with FLAC by dBpoweramp. And since it can read and verify, I don't understand why it can't repair.

CUETools DB
Reply #183
Does it let you convert without repair? I only have one theory so far - maybe there's an oversized (above 1m) artwork in source folder? 2.1.5 is unintentionally picky about that.
CUETools 2.1.4

  • Eli
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #184
Does it let you convert without repair? I only have one theory so far - maybe there's an oversized (above 1m) artwork in source folder? 2.1.5 is unintentionally picky about that.


Ding! Ding! Ding!

Yup, 1.1mb folder.jpg. Moved it and repaired NP!

I would never have guessed that one.

Hopefully that bug gets squashed.

CUETools DB
Reply #185
When ripping a disc with short silent pregaps, AccurateRip says it's ok, but CUETools DB always say some samples differ.
So I try to repair it with CUETools, but nothing happens, and CUETools' output log determines it's accurate on CUETools DB.

Should I be concerned with this or is this normal behaviour? BTW, my CD drive can't read pregaps.

Here is the EAC log of Suzanne Vega's S/T. Note the CUETools DB section of the log says some samples differ.

Code: [Select]
Exact Audio Copy V1.0 beta 3 from 29. August 2011

EAC extraction logfile from 2. June 2013, 22:21

Suzanne Vega / Suzanne Vega

Used drive  : HL-DT-STDVD-ROM GDR8161B  Adapter: 1  ID: 0

Read mode : Burst

Read offset correction                      : 102
Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out          : No
Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes
Delete leading and trailing silent blocks  : No
Null samples used in CRC calculations      : Yes
Used interface                              : Native Win32 interface for Win NT & 2000

Used output format              : User Defined Encoder
Selected bitrate                : 1024 kBit/s
Quality                        : High
Add ID3 tag                    : No
Command line compressor        : C:\Program Files\Exact Audio Copy\Flac\flac.exe
Additional command line options : -8 -V -T "ARTIST=%artist%" -T "ALBUM=%albumtitle%" -T "DATE=%year%" -T "GENRE=%genre%" -T "COMMENT=%comment%" -T "COMPOSER=%composer%" -T "TOTALTRACKS=%numtracks%" %source% -o %dest%


TOC of the extracted CD

     Track |  Start  |  Length  | Start sector | End sector
   ---------------------------------------------------------
       1  |  0:00.32 |  2:50.45 |        32    |    12826 
       2  |  2:51.02 |  2:36.25 |    12827    |    24551 
       3  |  5:27.27 |  3:40.23 |    24552    |    41074 
       4  |  9:07.50 |  3:55.45 |    41075    |    58744 
       5  | 13:03.20 |  3:48.72 |    58745    |    75916 
       6  | 16:52.17 |  3:28.03 |    75917    |    91519 
       7  | 20:20.20 |  3:41.00 |    91520    |  108094 
       8  | 24:01.20 |  4:51.15 |    108095    |  129934 
       9  | 28:52.35 |  3:36.70 |    129935    |  146204 
       10  | 32:29.30 |  3:20.55 |    146205    |  161259 


Range status and errors

Selected range

     Filename C:\EAC Temp\Suzanne Vega - Suzanne Vega.wav

     Peak level 91.2 %
     Extraction speed 22.2 X
     Copy CRC B55735BF
     Copy OK

No errors occurred

 
AccurateRip summary
 
Track  1  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [F35EFB10]  (AR v1)
Track  2  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [C8D7A41C]  (AR v1)
Track  3  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [65350556]  (AR v1)
Track  4  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [11E12428]  (AR v1)
Track  5  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [2528CCFA]  (AR v1)
Track  6  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [B952A494]  (AR v1)
Track  7  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [E06BE4DF]  (AR v1)
Track  8  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [B199FC80]  (AR v1)
Track  9  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [899AD981]  (AR v1)
Track 10  accurately ripped (confidence 6)  [ADB6953C]  (AR v1)
 
All tracks accurately ripped

End of status report

---- CUETools DB Plugin V2.1.3

[CTDB TOCID: Qg0b_gWtEeWHdK7xH1oZi2f.i_Q-] found, Submit result: discs with pregaps not supported in this protocol version
[e7389015] (359/359) Differs in 10921 samples @00:00:35-00:00:50
You can use CUETools to repair this rip.


==== Log checksum CC54404B0A57187EB1927F0F834AC46826EB66252E7D0629CFAD2C0E56AAA904 ====

So I try to repair it and this is the CUETools log, where after verification, nothing happens (no repair done even though it was selected)
Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 6/6/2013 11:52:45 AM; Version: 2.1.5]
Pregap length 00:00:32.
[CTDB TOCID: Qg0b_gWtEeWHdK7xH1oZi2f.i_Q-] found.
Track | CTDB Status
  1  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  2  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  3  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  4  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  5  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  6  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  7  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  8  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
  9  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
 10  | (7/7) Accurately ripped
[AccurateRip ID: 000cf8f3-0069a54a-7908660a] found.
Track  [  CRC  |  V2  ] Status
 01    [f35efb10|526aaef9] (006+000/509) Accurately ripped
 02    [c8d7a41c|707d0538] (006+000/510) Accurately ripped
 03    [65350556|0e71e2fe] (006+000/513) Accurately ripped
 04    [11e12428|93d775d4] (006+000/510) Accurately ripped
 05    [2528ccfa|57a1f977] (006+000/508) Accurately ripped
 06    [b952a494|8f5c4f83] (006+000/510) Accurately ripped
 07    [e06be4df|359e04ca] (006+000/508) Accurately ripped
 08    [b199fc80|10e4f764] (006+000/510) Accurately ripped
 09    [899ad981|2aca0bbf] (006+000/511) Accurately ripped
 10    [adb6953c|42fe7c91] (006+000/506) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 664:
 01    [a65516ad] (005/509) Accurately ripped
 02    [f14b992c] (005/510) Accurately ripped
 03    [710cf9b7] (005/513) Accurately ripped
 04    [4912f162] (005/510) Accurately ripped
 05    [7810f2a6] (005/508) Accurately ripped
 06    [b47e2297] (005/510) Accurately ripped
 07    [c03f9724] (005/508) Accurately ripped
 08    [229b4257] (005/510) Accurately ripped
 09    [78ace0fb] (005/511) Accurately ripped
 10    [de733224] (005/506) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 1328:
 01    [7d991df3] (053/509) Accurately ripped
 02    [6292d017] (053/510) Accurately ripped
 03    [9378df28] (054/513) Accurately ripped
 04    [3ba6ee76] (053/510) Accurately ripped
 05    [4a8c9c15] (052/508) Accurately ripped
 06    [7c708585] (053/510) Accurately ripped
 07    [d03dfc37] (053/508) Accurately ripped
 08    [196d23b0] (054/510) Accurately ripped
 09    [9480a3da] (053/511) Accurately ripped
 10    [d9632cc2] (052/506) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 1982:
 01    [27787140] (043/509) Accurately ripped
 02    [cb71f1f9] (043/510) Accurately ripped
 03    [f5565a73] (043/513) Accurately ripped
 04    [55534188] (043/510) Accurately ripped
 05    [6a875136] (043/508) Accurately ripped
 06    [ececab74] (043/510) Accurately ripped
 07    [0af0849b] (043/508) Accurately ripped
 08    [83e17263] (043/510) Accurately ripped
 09    [d1fa8789] (043/511) Accurately ripped
 10    [04b48f17] (043/506) Accurately ripped

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL] [  LOG  ]
 --  91.1 [B55735BF] [DEF7E937]  CRC32 
 01  70.0 [C5A70BBB] [D07C3176]         
 02  76.9 [6D8B2C76] [6C946E4B]         
 03  86.2 [1D5F1DA9] [9F0AACFB]         
 04  73.9 [7DBF081B] [2B646C08]         
 05  84.0 [FB88C3B1] [A15421C2]         
 06  73.1 [B36FEC9C] [5AA1459C]         
 07  83.1 [ED92E0DA] [BC371C4B]         
 08  84.6 [C92788E9] [65F4967B]         
 09  82.4 [30445AB9] [9DD4B33C]         
 10  91.1 [2BBFDF5D] [09642A81]         

Here is another example, a more modern CD, the latest from RHCP. The EAC and CUETools logs are shown below.

Code: [Select]
Exact Audio Copy V1.0 beta 3 from 29. August 2011

EAC extraction logfile from 3. June 2013, 12:30

Red Hot Chili Peppers / I'm with You

Used drive  : HL-DT-STDVD-ROM GDR8161B  Adapter: 1  ID: 0

Read mode              : Secure
Utilize accurate stream : Yes
Defeat audio cache      : Yes
Make use of C2 pointers : No

Read offset correction                      : 102
Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out          : No
Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes
Delete leading and trailing silent blocks  : No
Null samples used in CRC calculations      : Yes
Used interface                              : Native Win32 interface for Win NT & 2000

Used output format              : User Defined Encoder
Selected bitrate                : 1024 kBit/s
Quality                        : High
Add ID3 tag                    : No
Command line compressor        : C:\Program Files\Exact Audio Copy\Flac\flac.exe
Additional command line options : -8 -V -T "ARTIST=%artist%" -T "ALBUM=%albumtitle%" -T "DATE=%year%" -T "GENRE=%genre%" -T "COMMENT=%comment%" -T "COMPOSER=%composer%" -T "TOTALTRACKS=%numtracks%" %source% -o %dest%


TOC of the extracted CD

     Track |  Start  |  Length  | Start sector | End sector
   ---------------------------------------------------------
       1  |  0:00.15 |  4:12.32 |        15    |    18946 
       2  |  4:12.47 |  4:21.46 |    18947    |    38567 
       3  |  8:34.18 |  5:39.61 |    38568    |    64053 
       4  | 14:14.04 |  3:51.00 |    64054    |    81378 
       5  | 18:05.04 |  3:40.61 |    81379    |    97939 
       6  | 21:45.65 |  3:28.00 |    97940    |  113539 
       7  | 25:13.65 |  4:43.03 |    113540    |  134767 
       8  | 29:56.68 |  4:21.65 |    134768    |  154407 
       9  | 34:18.58 |  3:52.67 |    154408    |  171874 
       10  | 38:11.50 |  3:33.09 |    171875    |  187858 
       11  | 41:44.59 |  5:35.67 |    187859    |  213050 
       12  | 47:20.51 |  4:01.09 |    213051    |  231134 
       13  | 51:21.60 |  4:22.17 |    231135    |  250801 
       14  | 55:44.02 |  3:45.40 |    250802    |  267716 


Range status and errors

Selected range

     Filename C:\EAC Temp\Red Hot Chili Peppers - I'm with You.wav

     Peak level 100.0 %
     Extraction speed 4.5 X
     Range quality 99.9 %
     Copy CRC E14194A9
     Copy OK

No errors occurred

 
AccurateRip summary
 
Track  1  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [1E4C821A]  (AR v2)
Track  2  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [DF54E998]  (AR v2)
Track  3  accurately ripped (confidence 50)  [DD6BA9B1]  (AR v2)
Track  4  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [33BF41DB]  (AR v2)
Track  5  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [6F3DA516]  (AR v2)
Track  6  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [51B6CC56]  (AR v2)
Track  7  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [4A5A1A27]  (AR v2)
Track  8  accurately ripped (confidence 50)  [0D03EF5A]  (AR v2)
Track  9  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [6AE09ADB]  (AR v2)
Track 10  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [C0E3384A]  (AR v2)
Track 11  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [4BF260FF]  (AR v2)
Track 12  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [71D84C9C]  (AR v2)
Track 13  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [FB76FC8F]  (AR v2)
Track 14  accurately ripped (confidence 51)  [AB1AD69D]  (AR v2)
 
All tracks accurately ripped

End of status report

---- CUETools DB Plugin V2.1.3

[CTDB TOCID: Z05mxINrbJ8ZVnge2ceC6GJBBec-] found, Submit result: discs with pregaps not supported in this protocol version
[a8d49654] (103/104) Differs in 5708 samples @00:00:20-00:00:25
[5362c05c] (001/104) No match
You can use CUETools to repair this rip.


==== Log checksum 0E8BBE6B99745A38676DA3BD6D4AB014520D71F2D942AA70D452A7F5CF741685 ====

Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 6/6/2013 11:53:15 AM; Version: 2.1.5]
Pregap length 00:00:15.
[CTDB TOCID: Z05mxINrbJ8ZVnge2ceC6GJBBec-] found.
Track | CTDB Status
  1  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  2  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  3  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  4  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  5  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  6  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  7  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  8  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
  9  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
 10  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
 11  | (15/17) Accurately ripped
 12  | (14/17) Accurately ripped
 13  | (15/17) Accurately ripped
 14  | (16/17) Accurately ripped
[AccurateRip ID: 001eea4a-0148ae9d-bf0df10e] found.
Track  [  CRC  |  V2  ] Status
 01    [b78679fc|1e4c821a] (071+051/242) Accurately ripped
 02    [40dac34c|df54e998] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 03    [d78d5829|dd6ba9b1] (072+050/242) Accurately ripped
 04    [ac33068f|33bf41db] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 05    [d81eed38|6f3da516] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 06    [96c419f8|51b6cc56] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 07    [ba674fef|4a5a1a27] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 08    [7507b370|0d03ef5a] (072+050/243) Accurately ripped
 09    [269855ff|6ae09adb] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 10    [7ad627c7|c0e3384a] (072+051/244) Accurately ripped
 11    [b6523423|4bf260ff] (072+051/243) Accurately ripped
 12    [4938a7d4|71d84c9c] (071+051/242) Accurately ripped
 13    [f986d470|fb76fc8f] (071+051/241) Accurately ripped
 14    [6a0c1386|ab1ad69d] (068+051/240) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by -68:
 01    [44bd3978] (002/242) Accurately ripped
 02    [18d70fdf] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 03    [2d3ab6d3] (002/242) Accurately ripped
 04    [f84df1c0] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 05    [fdbb92a4] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 06    [e6c440e7] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 07    [58aa65f4] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 08    [70d1303a] (002/243) Accurately ripped
 09    [3a01940d] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 10    [76c84be3] (002/244) Accurately ripped
 11    [6963dffd] (002/243) Accurately ripped
 12    [53b57709] (002/242) Accurately ripped
 13    [197df91b] (002/241) Accurately ripped
 14    [1548e44e] (002/240) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 6:
 01    [67644587] (031/242) Accurately ripped
 02    [0677fa98] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 03    [32faa2b1] (031/242) Accurately ripped
 04    [bcad8a85] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 05    [d9b1e6d5] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 06    [5cf2184b] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 07    [5eb0f830] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 08    [cc16642a] (031/243) Accurately ripped
 09    [7e2be00f] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 10    [ac395338] (031/244) Accurately ripped
 11    [a84dd667] (031/243) Accurately ripped
 12    [9a985450] (031/242) Accurately ripped
 13    [14f63347] (031/241) Accurately ripped
 14    [108ff469] (031/240) Accurately ripped
Offsetted by 12:
 01    [bbca82d3] (039/242) Accurately ripped
 02    [e42252dc] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 03    [8f47975d] (040/242) Accurately ripped
 04    [afef0e7d] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 05    [21742c47] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 06    [642ec1fc] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 07    [dd42452c] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 08    [4c9037bc] (040/243) Accurately ripped
 09    [d619210d] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 10    [805ed9a6] (040/244) Accurately ripped
 11    [70a4dab2] (039/243) Accurately ripped
 12    [95affb69] (039/242) Accurately ripped
 13    [bdd5f004] (038/241) Accurately ripped
 14    [b723d551] (039/240) Accurately ripped

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL] [  LOG  ]
 --  100.0 [E14194A9] [3845DFCA]  CRC32 
 01  100.0 [232AE82E] [6C108268]         
 02  100.0 [C41EDE35] [0C5A877F]         
 03  100.0 [8C7394E9] [F79D8FCF]         
 04  100.0 [A601C4D5] [F6E8AB22]         
 05  100.0 [C1834BBB] [B0902F80]         
 06  100.0 [BEDA7784] [E044784E]         
 07  100.0 [965B33F1] [61119B89]         
 08  100.0 [0D2283E4] [8C793781]         
 09  100.0 [BAA82B49] [31DE3286]         
 10  100.0 [FAEAF6F0] [D3A0C125]         
 11  100.0 [FA306F45] [6B7D36EF]         
 12  100.0 [5072D66A] [B3D87E5A]         
 13  100.0 [8B6B13AF] [A3960C93]         
 14  100.0 [198A6DFA] [ED81A1CC]         

CUETools DB
Reply #186
"discs with pregaps not supported in this protocol version"

Your rips are ok. You are just using an old version of CTDB EAC plugin.

You can download the new one here: http://www.cuetools.net/wiki/CTDB_EAC_Plugin
CUETools 2.1.4

CUETools DB
Reply #187
"discs with pregaps not supported in this protocol version"

Your rips are ok. You are just using an old version of CTDB EAC plugin.

You can download the new one here: http://www.cuetools.net/wiki/CTDB_EAC_Plugin


Thanks for the link, I didn't know it was available for download separately. I thought it just came with EAC.

  • Eli
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #188
Having an odd situation:

Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 7/3/2013 10:34:49 AM; Version: 2.1.5]
[CTDB TOCID: mzwdPKfBtGHL5aUjLD8FvCt7Lq8-] found.
Track | CTDB Status
  1  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  2  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  3  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  4  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  5  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  6  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  7  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  8  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
  9  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
 10  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
 11  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
 12  | (3/3) Accurately ripped
 13  | (3/3) Differs in 1605 samples @06:04:27,06:14:04-06:14:05,06:16:36-06:16:37,06:17:02,06:17:22,06:18:08,06:18:68-06:18:69,06:19:34,06:19:74,06:21:25-06:21:26,06:21:45-06:21:46,06:22:11,06:23:17,06:23:57,06:24:43,06:24:63-06:24:64,06:25:08-06:25:09,06:26:14-06:26:15,06:27:20-06:27:21,06:27:41,06:29:12,06:30:18,06:32:10,06:32:50-06:32:51,06:34:22,06:35:08,06:35:68-06:35:69,06:37:20,06:37:40,06:37:60,06:38:06,06:38:26,06:38:66,06:39:32,06:40:38,06:40:58,06:41:03-06:41:04,06:41:24,06:41:44,06:41:64,06:42:10,06:42:30,06:42:70-06:42:71,06:44:62,06:45:48,06:47:40,06:47:60-06:47:61,06:49:32,06:51:04,06:52:71,06:53:16,06:53:57
[AccurateRip ID: 001add78-010f2411-a40efc0d] found.
Track  [  CRC  |  V2  ] Status
 01    [0bf217c9|067165db] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 02    [796a4f21|aaf4cc9b] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 03    [700eea07|9ca0f8c7] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 04    [5038bf10|569e6bdc] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 05    [17ee826f|046fec78] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 06    [099116a7|03cbd736] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 07    [eb01b984|1b60b060] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 08    [5f7d4d8e|2c1d0bc0] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 09    [be7c196b|0c80f699] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 10    [5a968f4c|85b58f1e] (24+03/27) Accurately ripped
 11    [d83fb6f7|e6389b96] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 12    [a95a221b|a63b20cb] (24+03/27) Accurately ripped
 13    [9a348df7|a727961a] (00+00/26) No match

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL]
 --  100.0 [8AA47F2C] [33AFE4A4]         
 01  100.0 [8A76B48A] [07AF1899]         
 02  100.0 [CB4302D3] [A795B85D]         
 03  100.0 [4846CCC0] [CA291DE9]         
 04  99.9 [EAACE5C5] [6D145D55]         
 05  100.0 [800E9F13] [3DBCD818]         
 06  100.0 [62885B5C] [44FECE35]         
 07  100.0 [DE9C8A49] [3F149FE0]         
 08  100.0 [5E78D45D] [6DD6D8E7]         
 09  100.0 [2C14DAC6] [A1FAB7D8]         
 10  100.0 [F17B60E5] [6FB2ACF5]         
 11  100.0 [AF5734FC] [741D2828]         
 12  100.0 [86AE24B2] [67041A35]         
 13  100.0 [21C22BED] [92D9AC11]         

This disc looks like it should be repairable.
However, using 2.1.5, I go through the repair process and I get:

Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 7/3/2013 10:53:23 AM; Version: 2.1.5]
[AccurateRip ID: 001add78-010f2411-a40efc0d] found.
Track  [  CRC  |  V2  ] Status
 01    [0bf217c9|067165db] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 02    [796a4f21|aaf4cc9b] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 03    [700eea07|9ca0f8c7] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 04    [5038bf10|569e6bdc] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 05    [17ee826f|046fec78] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 06    [099116a7|03cbd736] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 07    [eb01b984|1b60b060] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 08    [5f7d4d8e|2c1d0bc0] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 09    [be7c196b|0c80f699] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 10    [5a968f4c|85b58f1e] (24+03/27) Accurately ripped
 11    [d83fb6f7|e6389b96] (25+03/28) Accurately ripped
 12    [a95a221b|a63b20cb] (24+03/27) Accurately ripped
 13    [9a348df7|a727961a] (00+00/26) No match

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL]
 --  100.0 [8AA47F2C] [33AFE4A4]         
 01  100.0 [8A76B48A] [07AF1899]         
 02  100.0 [CB4302D3] [A795B85D]         
 03  100.0 [4846CCC0] [CA291DE9]         
 04  99.9 [EAACE5C5] [6D145D55]         
 05  100.0 [800E9F13] [3DBCD818]         
 06  100.0 [62885B5C] [44FECE35]         
 07  100.0 [DE9C8A49] [3F149FE0]         
 08  100.0 [5E78D45D] [6DD6D8E7]         
 09  100.0 [2C14DAC6] [A1FAB7D8]         
 10  100.0 [F17B60E5] [6FB2ACF5]         
 11  100.0 [AF5734FC] [741D2828]         
 12  100.0 [86AE24B2] [67041A35]         
 13  100.0 [21C22BED] [92D9AC11] 

CUETools DB
Reply #189
Just for this cd, or is repair generally broken in latest 2.1.5?
CUETools 2.1.4

  • Eli
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #190
sorry, for some reason CT had switched from repair mode to encode mode...

  • drfr
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #191
Don´t know if I understand this log correctly.
CTDBID: what do the lines 4 and 5 with a comma mean? Rips with extra  data track, I suppose?
ARID: how to interprete these? All submissions without extra data track?


Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 24. 9. 2013 12:38:54; Version: 2.1.5]
CD-Extra data track length 03:53:62.
[CTDB TOCID: psc7oJ_dm56UJM94MfL1VjlYeDQ-] found.
        [ CTDBID ] Status
        [65ee1459] (20/65) No match
        [6a30aaf3] (06/65) Has no data track, Accurately ripped
        [ef7f65fe] (02/65) Has no data track, No match
        [07899421] (35/65) , Accurately ripped
        [18363f86] (01/65) , No match
        [a83d9063] (01/65) No match
Track | CTDB Status
  1   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  2   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  3   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  4   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  5   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  6   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  7   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  8   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
  9   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
10   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
11   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
12   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
13   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
14   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
15   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
16   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
17   | (42/65) Accurately ripped
18   | (41/65) Accurately ripped
[AccurateRip ID: 002bbebc-0237a41b-1c0f8c13] found.
Track   [  CRC   |   V2   ] Status
01     [b1c3c382|04b613f2] (000+000/152) No match
02     [fa14ab2d|669b86fd] (000+000/156) No match
03     [406c3308|efa31aeb] (000+000/156) No match
04     [8f884ad0|1c78ae74] (000+000/157) No match
05     [e9911840|61072316] (000+000/155) No match
06     [e6889373|12424fea] (000+000/154) No match
07     [6247eb3e|6f865449] (000+000/156) No match
08     [8b0f1141|17893bfc] (000+000/154) No match
09     [81aa71e9|8c52f988] (000+000/152) No match
10     [857fd4f2|11f7d852] (000+000/153) No match
11     [3263472c|381d6854] (000+000/154) No match
12     [d69566f0|906bbf64] (000+000/153) No match
13     [15cafdcf|c65782ad] (000+000/154) No match
14     [5902383a|740322e7] (000+000/155) No match
15     [2809b5e6|a62f53b9] (000+000/153) No match
16     [24e09729|51974ee5] (000+000/150) No match
17     [04ca1f8d|0ed1e000] (000+000/150) No match
18     [9acfa964|7f3e285f] (000+000/149) No match

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL]
--   98,7 [8BA73C6D] [2854A0A6]          
01   98,7 [326B9AD4] [AF5D23A1]          
02   98,7 [EDD4F0E7] [A723FB04]          
03   98,7 [08DF454F] [68014E4C]          
04   98,7 [B5E13BE3] [0ADE82AD]          
05   98,7 [D4F6C0EC] [C3562EB0]          
06   98,7 [CAD27194] [DBCA2364]          
07   98,7 [F40D7FA4] [132460B7]          
08   98,7 [AE5A321A] [42BD4153]          
09   98,7 [36DB26F7] [AD622910]          
10   98,7 [5B331A41] [60657964]          
11   83,0 [B2C34CBA] [0AB523FD]          
12   98,7 [7CC3BA94] [81733D93]          
13   98,7 [E65885C1] [22A6551F]          
14   58,2 [4BA11EAA] [E1DED7BE]          
15   98,7 [304B19E2] [9402F6D0]          
16   98,7 [F5B3A86F] [A0F39AD9]          
17   98,7 [674BF278] [FD5B7723]          
18   78,2 [43727891] [E86C78A6]
  • Last Edit: 24 September, 2013, 07:53:35 AM by drfr

  • korth
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #192
Quote
CTDBID: what do the lines 4 and 5 with a comma mean? Rips with extra data track, I suppose?

It's a [a href='index.php?act=findpost&pid=837616']known bug[/a]. It should tell you CD-Extra data track length 03:54:17 before the comma.

Quote
ARID: how to interprete these? All submissions without extra data track?

The records under this AccurateRip ID included the data track and length. Some reading about AccurateRip ID calculation [[a href='index.php?showtopic=79082']link[/a]] [[a href='index.php?showtopic=53583']link[/a]].
A few reasons for the lack of matches could be you have
  • a different release using the same layout that hasn't been submitted to the database.
  • a different pressing with an offset that's out of range of CUETool's cross-pressing 'Offsetted by' listing under this section.
  • manually entered the wrong CD-Extra data track length into CUETools.
  • Last Edit: 24 September, 2013, 09:42:18 AM by korth
korth

  • drfr
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #193
It should tell you CD-Extra data track length 03:54:17 before the comma.


Thanks, that is a correct track length. How did you know?
  • Last Edit: 30 September, 2013, 02:17:27 AM by drfr

  • korth
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #194
Code: [Select]
[CUETools log; Date: 24. 9. 2013 12:38:54; Version: 2.1.5]
CD-Extra data track length 03:53:62.
[CTDB TOCID: [color=#FF0000][b]psc7oJ_dm56UJM94MfL1VjlYeDQ-[/b][/color]] found.
       [ CTDBID ] Status
       [65ee1459] (20/65) No match
       [6a30aaf3] (06/65) Has no data track, Accurately ripped
       [ef7f65fe] (02/65) Has no data track, No match
       [[color=#FF0000][b]07899421[/b][/color]] (35/65) , Accurately ripped
       [[color=#FF0000][b]18363f86[/b][/color]] (01/65) , No match
       [a83d9063] (01/65) No match
It was in the database
CUETools Database TOCID: psc7oJ_dm56UJM94MfL1VjlYeDQ-
Click 07899421 or 18363f86 in the CTDB Id column. Look on 2nd page of the Track section.
korth

  • drfr
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #195
CUETools Database TOCID: psc7oJ_dm56UJM94MfL1VjlYeDQ-


Actually I was looking for a way how to look up a CTDB TOCID in the database, didn ´t know it was that easy. Is this documented somewhere? Not in the wiki AFAIK.

  • korth
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #196
The wiki has a link to the database web page. I didn't plan to add documentation of this type to the wiki but I can. I'm so far behind updating pages already though.
Search by 'tocid' using db.cuetools.net/?tocid=
Search by 'artist' (most recent first) using db.cuetools.net/?artist=
Search by 'artist' (most popular first) using db.cuetools.net/top.php?artist=
of course you need to fill in missing data after the '=' such as db.cuetools.net/top.php?artist=adele
  • Last Edit: 30 September, 2013, 03:22:32 PM by korth
korth

  • ebz777
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #197
It doesn't seem very fair - people that would be wasting their CPU cycles to calculate those fingerprints would be helping a completely different category of users to identify random mp3s.

It is not for random mp3s actually. When I buy a compilation and when I rip it, I like to know to which original album releases the tracks correspond. Then I like also to be able to deconstruct that compilation and tag each individual tracks with the meta data of the original album releases, with a high certainty that these are the right albums.

Today I cannot do these if I don’t also own the albums, because it is often not possible to find out that information through the compilation liner notes and CUETools DB track CRCs are no help because they are two precise. If tomorrow CUETools DB contained the AcoustID of all tracks, we could determine which tracks we are actually buying and ripping.

It's quite fast to calculate an AcoustID, but I understand that some persons, sensitive to the time their rip takes or to the number of CPU cycles are opposed to calculate and publish them. However this concern could be overcome by providing this calculation as an option. That way, those persons could keep the option disabled. This should not be a problem for the database. It is sufficient after all if for each Disc Id just one person is motivated enough to calculate the AcoustID once in order to have that information available in the database attached to every track.

  • bilbo
  • [*][*][*]
CUETools DB
Reply #198
@ebz777

There are already several programs out there that use the MusicBainz database to identify tracks. Picard is one of them. They put the acoustic id in the tags and give you all the tag info. IIRC, MP3Tag also uses MusicBainz for retrieving tags. Have you tried this route? If there are programs that do what you want, why reinvent the wheel here?
Glass half full!

  • ebz777
  • [*]
CUETools DB
Reply #199
@ebz777

There are already several programs out there that use the MusicBainz database to identify tracks. Picard is one of them. They put the acoustic id in the tags and give you all the tag info. IIRC, MP3Tag also uses MusicBainz for retrieving tags. Have you tried this route? If there are programs that do what you want, why reinvent the wheel here?

I’m using MusicBrainz/AcoustID through Picard and Jaikoz. Unfortunately fingerprints in acoustid.org are linked to recordings in MusicBrainz not to Disc IDs. MusicBrainz/AcoustID rely on these current tagging softwares to calculate the fingerprints and associate them to recordings. Since these software work at the track level and not the disc level they have no better option.

And these tagging softwares can’t also force any particular workflow. So you end up having users tagging a bunch of mp3’s and polluting the database by associating them with the wrong recordings. In the end it’s a useless mess for the purpose I was describing.

Only a special ripping software like Cuetools could calculate a fingerprint for each track and ensure that they are associated together properly with a unique Disc ID.