Skip to main content

Topic: Tagging old flacs with new flac version (Read 2699 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
  • Emanuel
  • [*][*][*][*]
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
In my setup, I use flac 1.1.0 but have many early flac encodings on my harddrive. Are there any problems to use the new flac for tagging old flacs?
I guess the question should be breaken down to two sub-questions regarding:
1. tagging flac 1.0.4
2. tagging pre flac 1.0.4

  • kritip
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
Reply #1
I belive all sub versions ie 1.0.1, 1.0.2, 1.0.3, et cetera are all meant to be compatible.
Sadly i discovered a bug with the cuesheets in a 1.05  beta that broke backkward compatability with 1.0.4 and below, hence the new verson update to 1.1.0. This may not have been the only reason for the version update though.

Due to this 1.1.0 files will not always decode with earlier decoder versions, but, i do belive that if you use metaflac from 1.1.0 on earlier versions then they will tag fine, you just won't be able to use them with the older decoders!

If this is not a problem then go ahead.

Of course i may be entirley wrong, you might wanna wait for Josh's input to be certain. I don't wanna be responsible for borking your collection!! 

Cheers,

Kristian

  • Amadablam
  • [*][*][*]
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
Reply #2
I'm not totally certain about this, but I believe the incompatibility only exists when you try to decode a 1.1-encoded flac with an embedded cuesheet with a pre-1.1 version of flac.  I'm guessing everything will be fine if you don't do anything with embedded cuesheets.  You might want to try a few test files first to make sure there aren't any problems.

  • jcoalson
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Developer
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
Reply #3
Quote
I'm not totally certain about this, but I believe the incompatibility only exists when you try to decode a 1.1-encoded flac with an embedded cuesheet with a pre-1.1 version of flac.  I'm guessing everything will be fine if you don't do anything with embedded cuesheets.

This is correct.

Josh

  • Emanuel
  • [*][*][*][*]
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
Reply #4
Thanks everyone. In my tests, there have been no obvious problems. But compatibility is such a big issue and it's easy to break it somewhere without knowing or noticing it immediately. I guess time will tell - now most of the files are tagged.

phew.

  • Emanuel
  • [*][*][*][*]
Tagging old flacs with new flac version
Reply #5
Thanks everyone. In my tests, there have been no obvious problems. But compatibility is such a big issue and it's easy to break it somewhere without knowing or noticing it immediately. I guess time will tell - now most of the files are tagged.

phew.