Skip to main content

Topic: the best testsongs? (Read 3232 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
the best testsongs?
hi

i wannt to test and find my own best mp3 settings, what are the best songs (pop mainly) for testing purposes?
what are your experiences?
i tested with these samples (sticky) and with some classical until now

bye

  • dev0
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Developer
the best testsongs?
Reply #1
Random songs from your collection should d the job just fine.

<edit>
ff123 had a good collection of 'real-world' samples for the 64kbps listening test. They are offline now, but I'm sure someone could mirror them...
</edit>

dev0
  • Last Edit: 04 December, 2002, 11:46:40 AM by dev0
"To understand me, you'll have to swallow a world." Or maybe your words.

  • Phaedras
  • [*]
the best testsongs?
Reply #2
I'd say if you want to find settings that work on most sorts of music reasonably well, you might want to try tracks that really bring an encoder to it's knees.

In my experience anything Acoustic (acoustic guitars are good) or percussion (hi-hat, cymbals) will definetely force the encoder to allocate a lot of bits. The Eric Clapton Unplugged session had a couple hard to encode songs. Also, stay away from Trip-Hop. Portishead compressed VERY nicely.

Oh, maybe I should mention that I primarily use Vorbis  B)  , but I think a hard-to-encode track is a hard-to-encode-track, regardless of codec.

  • ff123
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Developer (Donating)
the best testsongs?
Reply #3
Quote
Random songs from your collection should d the job just fine.

<edit>
ff123 had a good collection of 'real-world' samples for the 64kbps listening test. They are offline now, but I'm sure someone could mirror them...
</edit>

dev0

The samples used for the 64 kbps test are up at:

http://ff123.net/samples.html

ff123

the best testsongs?
Reply #4
thanks guys

  • Garf
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Developer (Donating)
the best testsongs?
Reply #5
IMHO the best testtracks are music you know well and like to listen to.

  • Beta
  • [*]
the best testsongs?
Reply #6
Quote
i wannt to test and find my own best mp3 settings, what are the best songs (pop mainly) for testing purposes?
what are your experiences?
i tested with these samples (sticky) and with some classical until now

I would recommend No Quarter by Led Zeppelin from Houses Of The Holy album.
The subtly distorted electric piano in the beginning totally kills Ogg Vorbis.
lame --alt-preset standard (3.92 compile so that might be the fault) isn't totally transparent either on the cymbals and I think I can differentiate even --alt-preset extreme from the original
Disclaimer: I haven't done ABX since the tests were done at a friend's place who has better stereos).