Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive? (Read 4166 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

I have a CD that has lots of scratches, and I can see black spots all around the CD. I'm trying to rip it with EAC but it's really slow... Secure mode says it will take 6 hours for just one track. I tried ripping with burst mode but it gives skips.

I then polished the CD with toothpaste, and now the ripped tracks (with burst mode) don't skip but I get a different CRC every time! Comparing the wavs gives different samples throughtout the whole track for all the files.

If I just let secure mode run until it finishes, will it damage my drive considering the huge amount of time and error correction?

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #1 –
Short answer: YES, it will wear down your drive.

EAC's secure mode is based on a "read-go back-read" method that will put an extra stress on the drive.
Don't worry though, it would take much more than just a single 6-hour-ripping session to kill a modern drive.

If you do not this often, you will not notice the impact of this event on your drive's life.
I'm the one in the picture, sitting on a giant cabbage in Mexico, circa 1978.
Reseñas de Rock en Español: www.estadogeneral.com

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #2 –
I always turn on the automatic cool down feature, and then when discs like this are going to be ripped then it will shut down the drive for a while to let it cool, and then start back up later on. I've changed mine to cool for 7 minutes after every 30 minutes of ripping. I believe the defaults are 15 after every 60? Not sure that mine's actually any better, just seemed safer to me. Might not even matter.

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #3 –
As it has been said, it can damage your drive. My brother killed his one shortly before he finished ripping as many CDs to MP3 as it takes to fill the original Creative DAP Jukebox (6 GB) in secure mode, including scratched CDs. It developed read errors, he couldn't install games etc. anymore. The drive hasn't been used for much else than ripping...

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #4 –
Does setting the cooling period help prolong the lifespan?

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #5 –
Quote
Does setting the cooling period help prolong the lifespan?

It is believed that "cooling" (I would rather call it drive stand-by) helps on that issue ... but you may consider that there are already high temperatures in most modern pc casings ... so cooling down will only show results if the heat produced by the drive's motor can be transported out of the casing and this will only happen quickly enough if a significant temperature gradient is present from drive surface to pc internals ...

You might consider using a dvd drive for ripping of damaged CD's ... DVD drives are believed to be more suitable for long-term runs (over some 2 hours during DVD playback as an example) than CD-ROM drives ...
The name was Plex The Ripper, not Jack The Ripper

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #6 –
Do EAC report read errors ? If so, Try to rip a short part and see if anything is improved over burst mode. If not, it's not worth doing it. Secure mode was not designed to recover damaged CDs, just to warn that they are.

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #7 –
I'm not sure if EAC will give a read error (probably will), as I just cancelled it after 5 minutes of ripping seeing that it will take so long. But if I do 2 secure mode rips of the first few seconds of the first track, and compare them I get no differences found. Whereas if I use burst mode, differences are found in almost all the samples...

Will ripping a bad CD with EAC damage my drive?

Reply #8 –
Try repolishing the read surface of the cd. There are numerous threads on ways to do this.