Skip to main content

Topic: gapless encodes? (Read 18056 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
  • Larsus
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Hi All!

I own the Nomad Jukebox 40G. When playing mp3s of music that have no gaps (Pink Floyd, Porcupine Tree, etc.) there is a slight gap of silence between tracks. This bugs me to no end. So, on music that have no gaps I started using BladeEnc with the -nogap option (and use lame for evrything else). Does lame have an option like this or will it be getting this option? It is really nice to hear these albums play back gapless.

gapless encodes?
Reply #1
The mp3 format doesn't allow gapless encoding. So there's no real solution if you use a Nomad Jukebox.

If you want to listen to Pink Floyd, Porcupine Tree, etc albums without gaps between tracks, the only solution I know is to encode those albums as a single big track.

  • FuRaL
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #2
Quote
If you want to listen to Pink Floyd, Porcupine Tree, etc albums without gaps between tracks, the only solution I know is to encode those albums as a single big track.

... and the other possibility is using a better audio format like Ogg Vorbis or Musepack MPC. These formats are able to encode absolutely gapless and have at the same filesize as an mp3 file much better sound quality!

gapless encodes?
Reply #3
Quote
... and the other possibility is using a better audio format like Ogg Vorbis or Musepack MPC. These formats are able to encode absolutely gapless and have at the same filesize as an mp3 file much better sound quality!

My answer was referring to Larsus' question: "I own the Nomad Jukebox 40G...", which implies ha can't use another audio format but mp3 for his Nomad Jukebox.

Everybody here knows that the other possibility is to use another audio format (or foobar2000 to play mp3's).

  • Larsus
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #4
Actually, BladeEnc does provide a gapless solution. I would rather use Lame since it appears that development on the program is continual. BladeEnc is no longer being worked on.

Anyway, BladeEnc is the solution at the moment.

  • Larsus
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #5
...oh. On the JB I can also use wav (too big) or wma (yech)...

  • M
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #6
Yes, L.A.M.E. has a --nogap option. The simplest way to use it is with Speek's ALL2LAME frontend (just check the "No Gap" box in the "Gapless encoding" section), since that also automatically configures the necessary --nogapout parameter.

    - M.

  • Raffles
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #7
You could rip your cd's as a single file and then encode with Lame.

Using EAC under Action and Copy Range, you'll have a choice between ripping a compressed or uncompressed file.

The result will be a single wav or mp3, which should be just what you want for gapless playback on a portable.

I used this method for The Mars Volta's album "De-loused In the Comatorium", which sounded crap on my MuVo with gaps between the tracks that should have run into each other.

Raf.

  • Larsus
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #8
I'm going to try the --nogap option with A2L. That should also work with RazorLame, yes?

I'd rather not encode the whole CD as 1 file. I'd like to have the ability to change tracks. BladeEnc gave me clean (no ticks) gapless encodes. But, like I said, I'd rather use Lame.

I was putting these CDs onto my JB3 as wavs, which played gapless, but it was taking up too much space.

I'll let you know how that turns out.

  • Larsus
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #9
O.K. It worked!

Now I can use my encoder of choice (Lame) to create gapless mp3s. It's interesting to note that in the list of command parms for Lame --gapless is not listed.

Now I'll A/B the BladeEnc & Lame mp3s.

  • DickD
  • [*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #10
You can also get lame 3.90.3 with .APE and .CUE-sheet support from Rarewares. (Also a 'modified' version with added --preset medium and lower ABR presets is available)

EAC can create the WAV or Monkey's (.APE) image and a Cuesheet with artists and titles, then you can use this extended version of Lame to encode.

Instructions are on Nyaochi's website.

The commandline will be something like:
Code: [Select]
lame --apeinput --alt-preset standard -t CUESHEET CDImage.ape.cue "%n - %p - %t.mp3" --naming-rule


Gapless is usually a hack. The latest Foobar2000 v0.7 beta is supporting a VBR header type fix to allow you to make regular Lame MP3's play gapless properly, but that's not got portable support for the gapless feature, as it's stored in the VBR Xing/LAME header frame, which portables treat as a silent frame.

--nogap will remove the VBR header if you had a VBR encode, so track length and seeking may be messed up for VBR files if they rely on the Xing/LAME header. lame+APE+CUE by default puts in the VBR headers, but these are treated as valid silent frames by most portable players (fb2k is about the only software player that treats it right), thereby creating a tiny gap, so you need to revert to -t (the default LAME --nogap method) and remove the headers, as in my example commandline above. If it's just track shuffling that matters to you, this shouldn't be a big problem.

gapless encodes?
Reply #11
hi people,

i am currently using CDex Version 1.51 to rip mix cds. Now, i have it set up to use an external decoder ( ALL2LAME ) in order to make use of the nogap feature.

couple of questions:

firstly, with CDex - i rip the cd into wav files. and then use ALL2LAME to code them to mp3's.

the encoding is:  44.1 kHz / 128 kbps / j-stereo MPEG-1 Layer II / qcal=2

This is what ALL2LAME displays when encoding.

is this right? can i not encode anything higher than 128?

also, i seem to have to manually open up ALL2LAME and select the files, rather than CDex picking up the decoder automatically.

i dont mind the 128 kbps, but the main prob is that none of the file information (title, artist, year etc) is retained when ripping it from the cd into wav and then into mp3 - so i need to manually enter in the missing details.

is this something thats unavoidable?

when you rip a cd normally via CDex (using its own lame decoder) it retains all the info, as you would expect it to do.

any tips or hints?

the other problem is that when it decodes from to wav from the cd, it loses the track number - which means its a pain when using ALL2LAME (another case of manually renaming the files).

must be an easier way? (i'm hoping i've missed the obvious)
  • Last Edit: 01 January, 2004, 04:13:11 PM by PlastikFabric

  • kasztan
  • [*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #12
Quote
the encoding is:  44.1 kHz / 128 kbps / j-stereo MPEG-1 Layer II / qcal=2

i think MPEG-1 Layer III
and it will be better when you look at FAQ - very powerfull guide

  • saratoga
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #13
Rip directly to MP3.  Wav files do not support tagging, so if you include wav as a step you will lose metadata.  Theres no reason to use ALL2LAME anyway.

Edit:  And next time instead of digging up the corpse of an old thread and shoving your thread inside, start a fresh one.
  • Last Edit: 02 January, 2004, 12:26:54 AM by Mike Giacomelli

gapless encodes?
Reply #14
if i rip directly to mp3 and not use all2lame, how can i do so and still retain 'no gap' with the ripping?

sorry for breathing life into this old thread. i just thought it was relevant to what i am aiming to do.

for example, find a combination of programs that will allow me to rip with no gaps.


edit: sorry, i should have made it clear in my original post - that i am ripping cds which i do not wish to have sounds between the tracks. my aim is indentical to what Larsus aimed for.

using cdex and all2lame, i am able to do this - except it is time consuming (because of having to re-enter all the track details) and i can only achieve the 128.

the mp3's are then being transfered onto a Zen player.
  • Last Edit: 02 January, 2004, 08:54:59 AM by PlastikFabric

  • DonP
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Members (Donating)
gapless encodes?
Reply #15
You can encode the whole CD as one file.  There is a splitting program MP3Directcut which I believe splits your file up on frame boundaries.  So, no gaps.


Personally I don't find the inherent mp3 gap all that bothersome as it is on the order of 1/100 second.  Much worse is the large gap due to players that don't start reading the next track until the current one is done.  Have the Blade encodes been gapless for you?

gapless encodes?
Reply #16
not tried blade encodes.

but the MP3Directcut program sounds good as an alternative. will try that out now.

  • Joe Bloggs
  • [*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #17
Um, so what switch do I use to make these sorta-kinda gapless mp3s when directly using Lame.exe? --gapless? --nogapout? --nogap? Help?

  • saratoga
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #18
MP3s encoded with LAME are normally gapless.  AFAIK the --nogap option is depreciated (could be wrong though).  If it turns out that --nogap helps, just use it in EAC, CDex or whatever.

Here is what i do:  I rip with EAC and preset standard.  That produces gapless MP3s.  Then to burn them later to a disk I use foobar to make sure the decoder does not introduce a gap.

  • saratoga
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #19
Ah here we go:

Quote
--nogap is useless, deprecated, and hardly supported anywhere.
All recent versions of LAME (3.90 and above if I remember correctly) always write additional gapless playback info (amounts of samples to skip) into LAME tag (unless you disable LAME tag writing). All you need is a player that reads and utilizes info from LAME tag; see the topic linked above for more info.
And again, gapless playback using LAME tags has absolutely nothing to do with --nogap switch.


http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index....6020&hl=--nogap

  • Joe Bloggs
  • [*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #20
That wasn't much help--if LAME mp3s were gapless by default Larsus wouldn't have his problem in the first place. I'm having trouble with LAME mp3s in the Nomad Zen NX too--they don't play gaplessly, but there are plenty of other tracks on my player that do!

  • Joe Bloggs
  • [*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #21
Larsus, what are you doing to make gapless work with your player?

  • Peter
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Administrator
gapless encodes?
Reply #22
Some hardware players "support" --nogap by not resetting their MP3 decoders between tracks. I highly doubt if any hardware player supports LAME tags.
IMO more sane solution would be to upload entire album CD image as one MP3 track, that would work everywhere (but no track titles, starting playback from selected track, etc then).
  • Last Edit: 03 January, 2004, 05:41:45 AM by zZzZzZz

  • Joe Bloggs
  • [*][*][*][*]
gapless encodes?
Reply #23
Does (*gasp*) WMA support gapless playback?

  • Peter
  • [*][*][*][*][*]
  • Administrator
gapless encodes?
Reply #24
Quote
Does (*gasp*) WMA support gapless playback?

From what I've heard, yes.